Categories: Uncategorized

Analyzing the Illiad Books Assignment | Custom Assignment Help

Description

After reading The Iliad (Books 9-12), your task in this thread is to select the passage from Books 9-12 that you feel is most new and significant in relation to Books 1-8, and then post the following: The passage itself (with page numbers) A brief analytical statement from you about why this passage in particular seems most noteworthy in light of everything else we’ve read and discussed (no word count, but quality matters) Three analytical questions drawn from this week’s reading. An analytical question would be one that would allow any of the rest of us to respond with our thoughts and ideas, as opposed to a merely informational question (again, quality matters here; demonstrate in your questions themselves that you’re thinking seriously about the specific events and details from Books 9-12). Make sure to number your three questions. This is a discussion post which my teacher will be responding to. You are only allowed to use one source which is the book. I will provide a link to you in the chat to use for the book. It is the exact same version so, PLEASE STATE WHICH PAGE NUMBER THE PASSAGE YOU CHOSE WAS ON. I will provide samples of my writing so that you can see and write accordingly.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Analyzing the Illiad Books Assignment | Custom Assignment Help
Get an essay WRITTEN FOR YOU, Plagiarism free, and by an EXPERT!
Order Essay

Example 1:
It is evident that the gods play a crucial part in the life of the
humans of the Greek society. Homer illustrates people praying,
making offerings and sacrifices to please and humor the gods and
to receive good things their way. The gods are portrayed to be
way superior than the humans as the beginning passage starts,
“But Athena, with bright eyes, taking Ares in hand called the
violent god away with: “Ares, Ares, destroyer of men, reeking
blood, stormer of ramparts, why not let these mortals fight it out
for themselves? Let Zeus give glory to either side he chooses.
We’ll stay clear and escape the Father’s rage.” This shows the
dominance of power that the gods have over the humans. They
can retreat from a fight and just watch how the humans do. But
then shortly, she has a change of heart when Diomedes pleads
with her for strength to fight against the Trojans. “Now take heart
Diomedes, fight it out with the Trojans! … If Aphrodite, daughter of
Zeus slips into battle, she’s the one to stab with your sharp
bronze spear!” (pg. 168) Personally, I found this part a little funny
and petty. Because of the hatred that she has for her illegitimate
sister, she encourages Diomedes to hurt her.
Athena played a big part in the war between the Greeks and the
Trojans. I believe that without Athena’s constant meddling, the
Greeks would have won the war. Homer uses the gods to
intervene in human interactions to show that humans can not
escape their given fate. Hector gives this statement to his wife,
“Andromache, dear one, why so desperate? Why so much grief
for me? No man will hurl me down to Death, against my fate. And
fate? No one alive has ever escaped it, neither brave man nor
coward, I tell you – it’s born with us the day that we are born.” (pg.
212) This was an explanation that Hector knew that his life was in
the hands of the gods and that he had no way of changing their
way of making his life go. It was accepting his fate.
Hector is depicted to be the greatest leader and warrior in the
poem so far. While he cares about receiving fame and glory, he
does not let that shake his morals and values in the doing the just
thing. “All this weighs on my mind too dear woman. But I would
die of shame to face the men of Troy and the Trojan women
trailing their long robes if I would shrink from battle now. A
coward…” Hector was aware of the weight he carried in bringing
the Trojans to victory and saving his people. He was scared too,
but he did not let his fear or his greed stall him from receiving the
honor and glory of saving his people.
Example 2:
After reading Book 1 of the Iliad and observing the quarrel
between Agamemnon, the Lord of Men, and Achilles, one of the
greatest and most fearsome Greek warrior, I have come to the
conclusion that Achilles stands in the “right” position against
Agamemnon.
Agamemnon and the Archaean army, along with Achilles, capture
two maidens, Chryseis and Briseis, during their conquest over the
Trojans. The priest Chryses begs Agamemnon to return his
daughter safely to him, however, Agamemnon dismisses Chryses
and threatens him “let me catch sight of you by the hollow ship.
Not loitering now, not slinking back tomorrow. The staff and the
wreaths of god will never save you then” (pg. 79 – 30).
Agememnon’s greed to keep Chryseis by his side while having a
wife who he claims to be “nothing less in building or breed, in
mind or works of hand” (pg. 81 – 133) brings a plague of death
brought upon Chryses’s prayer to Apollo. While Apollo strikes
down death upon the Archaean army for ten days, Agamemnon
doesn’t bother to figure out why a plague has been brought upon
his army and is imbued with his own greed. It is not until Achilles
calls for Calchas the Seer to explain the cause of the plague. This
initial encounter already gives an impression of Agamemnon’s
character as a person and the leader of his army. He filled with
selfishness and greed and focuses on his own personal gains,
leaving no room for care for his own soldiers.
As Calchas states the cause behind the plague, Agamemnon is
filled with rage and demands that he will only return Chryseis in
return for another prize. He demands the Archaean army to “give
me a prize, a match for my desires, equal to what I’ve lost, well
and good. But if they give me nothing I will take a prize myself –
your own, or Ajax’ or Odysseus’ prize” (pg. 82 – 159). He is
referring to taking Achilles’s prize, Briseis, even after Achilles
offers Agamemnon to pay back a prize 3-4 times in value later on
for returning Chryseis at the moment. Agamemnon’s impatience
and greed results him to take Briseis from Achilles by force,
however, Achilles who is filled with anger and sorrow, allows the
couriers to take Briseis away without any resistance by remaining
calm and without acting upon his emotions. However, you are
able to understand his sorrow right after as he weeps and cries
out to his mother on the beach. During their quarrel, Achilles who
is about to strike and kill Agamemnon, is checked by the
goddesses Athena and Hera and he obediently restrains from
killing Agamemnon. After analyzing this scene of the story, we
come to understand Achilles’s character. While he is a fearsome
warrior, he is not only obedient and level-minded, but also just as
he offers Agamemnon a compensation for his lost prize. He also
displays a caring personality as he seeks to why a death plague
has been sent upon the Archaean army.
In conclusion, I believe Achilles’s stood in the correct position
because he put aside his pride and emotions by being obedient to
the Goddesses and yielding his prize to Agamemnon to stop the
suffering upon the Archaean army. Meanwhile, Agamemnon’s
greed and selfishness brought the death plague upon the
Archaean army and he had no thoughts to stop the suffering until
he received his prize.
This is a sample of what another student wrote… So that you get
an idea of what you’re supposed to do.
Example 1:
A. And the swift runner Achilles answered warmly, “Ajax, royal son
of Telamon, captain of armies, all well said, after my own heart, or
mostly so. But my heart still heaves with rage whenever I call to
mind that arrogance of his- how he mortified me, right in front of
the Argives- that son of Atreus treating me like some vagabond,
like some outcast stripped of all my rights! You go back to him and
declare my message: I will not think of arming for bloody war
again, not till the son of wise King Priam, dazzling Hector batters
all the way to the Myrmidon ships and shelters, slaughtering
Argives, gutting the hulls with fire. But round my own black ship
and camp this Hector blazing for battle will be stopped, I truststopped
dead in his tracks!” (page 273/p 786-801
B. I found this passage to be the most significant because it is the
first time we hear that Achilles will potentially fight! He refused to
fight after begging from Nestor and Agamemnon in earlier books.
In book 9 he is visited by Odysseus, Phoenix, and Ajax to deliver
a message from Agamemnon who promises the return of Briseus,
7 women, and many other riches if he will join them in fighting the
Trojans. Persuasive speeches are made by all three men, but
Achilles will hear none of it. He has no interest in the women or
the treasures. The only thing that will get him to fight is if Hector
reaches his camp.
This passage gave me some hope to finally see Achilles in action.
At the end of book 12, we see that Zeus helps Hector break down
the Greek rampart, thus giving an opportunity for Hector to invade
Achilles’ camp. Both Achilles and Hector are loved by Zeus, so it
will be interesting to see which way the fight will go in the next
books.
C.
1.) Do you think Zeus will follow through on his threat to punish
the gods that intervene, specifically Athena for breathing fury into
Diomedes so that he could surprise slaughter the Thracians?
(page 292)
2.) Why do you think Zeus flung Strife down on Greek ships to
give her high-pitched cry, lashing the fighting fury in the heart of
the Greeks to crave battle rather than sail home? Why does he
want them to battle if he favors the Trojans?(page 296)
3.) Why do you think Zeus sent Iris down to Hector with the
message to hold back from fighting until Agamemnon was
wounded by spear or arrow? (page 303)
Example 2:
A.
But now at last, stop, Achilles-let your heart-devouring
anger go! The king will hand you gifts to match his insults if only
you’ll relent and end your anger …
So come then, listen, as I count out the gifts, the troves in his
tents that Agamemnon vows to give you. Seven tripods never
touched by fire, ten bars of gold, twenty burnished cauldrons, a
dozen massive stallions, racers who earned him trophies with
their speed. He is no poor man who owns what they have won,
not strapped for goods with all that lovely gold what trophies those
high-strung horses carried off for him! Seven women he’ll give
you, flawless, skilled in crafts, women of Lesbos-the ones he
chose, his privilege,that day you captured the Lesbos citadel
yourself: they outclassed the tribes of women in their beauty.
These he will give, and along with them will go the one he took
away at first, Briseus’ daughter, and he will swear a solemn,
binding oath in the bargain: he never mounted her bed, never
once made love with her …the natural thing, my lord, men and
women joined. Now all these gifts will be handed you at once. But
if, later, the gods allow us to plunder the great city of Priam, you
shall enter in when we share the spoils, load the holds of your
ship with gold and bronze-as much as your heart desires-and
choose for your pleasure twenty Trojan women second only to
Argive Helen in their glory. And then, if we can journey home to
Achaean Argos, pride of the breasting earth, you’ll be his son-bymarriage
…He will even honor you on a par with his Orestes, fullgrown
by now, reared in the lap of luxury. Three daughters are his
in his well-built halls,
Chrysothemis and Laodice and Iphianassaand you may lead
away whichever one you like, with no bride-price asked, home to
Peleus’ house. And he will add a dowry, yes, a magnificent
treasure the likes of which no man has ever offered with his
daughter… .Seven citadels he will give you, filled with people,
Cardamyle, Bnope. and the grassy slopes of Hire, Pherae the
sacrosanct, Anthea deep in meadows, rolling Aepea and Pedasus
green with vineyards. All face the sea at the far edge of sandy
Pylos and the men who live within them, rich in sheep-flocks, rich
in shambling cattle, will honor you like a god with hoards of gifts
and beneath your scepter’s sway live out your laws in sleek and
shining peace. (Book 9, page 260: 315-361)
B.
At first glance, I feel overwhelmed when I read this
literally long passage, but in return, it contains two remarkable
threads that I found very interesting. Firstly, Odyseuss repeats
rewards that Agamemnon is willing to give Achilles a list of gifts to
weld their friendship and also promises to bestow Achilles a ton of
valuable things after their victory. That makes me think carefully
about wealth and treasures may possess the power to change a
person’s mind. Obviously, after blaming Agamemnon, he can not
make a decision, and then he askes Phoenix to decide for
him(page 266: 518-521). Secondly, in those of rewards,
Agamemnon promises to give Achilles “Seven citadels” after the
war that means Achilles will be a ruler of those cities. The
authority is more over than wealth. Being a ruler can let that
person own thousands of treasures and honor. With the authority
Achilles can reserve his glory of the Trojan Wars through
centuries. Eventually, Achilles can not decide by himself and must
rely on persuasions of Patroclus and Pheonix to help him to make
a final decision. In my opinion, even a demi-god like Achilles can
hesitate to make an option in front of a bargain offer including
wealth and authority of the ruler.
C.
1- While everyone is fighting drastically including Agamemnon,
Ajax, Odysseus, Diomedes,..etc, why does Achilles not help them
the battle (Book 11, page 316)? Does it make him a bad person
from the perspective of a comrade? And Why?
2- Patroclus is a best friend of Achilles and we see Patroclus often
obeys Achilles (page 258, page 316 ). In the strong friendship
between Patroclus and Achilles, can it exist a friend at a lower
position than the other friend? Why?
3- Does it make Hector powerless in his authority when Asius did
not follow the plan of Polydamas under the command of Hector
(Book 12, page 329)? Why?

Suzie Mercy

Recent Posts

What is the easy difination of science | Quick Solution

Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social…

4 years ago

definition, values, meaning of such values and type of goods with such elasticity value …….. | Quick Solution

Clearly stating the definition, the values, the meaning of such values and the type of…

4 years ago

Acct 422 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago

Acct 322 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago

Macro Economics Question | Quick Solution

https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/04/25/605092520/high-paying-trade-jobs-sit-empty-while-high-school-grads-line-up-for-university Click on the link above. Read the entire link and answer the questions below…

4 years ago

MGT 322 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago