Categories: Uncategorized

Role of delivery systems in Infrastructure management Assignment | Essay Help Services

Description

it is for a class called Alternative project delivery systems (CONSTRUCTION) The paper must be based on 5 articles, I worked on those that I have in the attached document (the fourth article is not related so must be replaced for a construction-related article) (((( Professor suggests I focus the paper on transportation infrastructure. ))))

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Role of delivery systems in Infrastructure management Assignment | Essay Help Services
Get an essay WRITTEN FOR YOU, Plagiarism free, and by an EXPERT!
Order Essay

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Role of Delivery Systems in Large Infrastructure Projects

Bruno Sanchez

Northeastern University

 

 

 

 

 

Abstract

 

 

Infrastructure management has always been important for the evolution of society, nations, and construction in general because the infrastructure projects are the improvements that provide the necessary assets, systems, and networks that countries require to grow. However, without proper management and delivery system, infrastructure projects would not be achievable. Several delivery systems can be used on construction projects. This paper will focus on the more popular ones. Project delivery systems such as construction management at risk, design-bid-build, design-build, progressive design-build, and multi-prime contracts offer project owners different options for value in infrastructure cost, quality, service, and technology. Delivery systems also connect to the owners’ approach in planning and organizing the project team that will manage the design and construction. This paper aims to identify the role of project delivery systems in large infrastructures. Moreover, interpreting the more practiced delivery system in the industry, their characteristics, and their potential role in infrastructure improvement. Since infrastructural projects always bring significant challenges due to their massive levels of uncertainty, complexity, and notorious costs and time overruns, it is common to see these projects miss in completing their original goals. Therefore, it will assist project owners in recognizing how project delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages assist in mitigating and mastering these challenges, considering that every project is different, and owners’ objectives vary from one to another.

 

 

This paper will also incorporate the three fundamental project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers. It will describe the different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers. Challenges include significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. The paper covers quality concerns of large infrastructural projects, pointing out that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. Its disposition is to explain that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy. It is even more challenging to meet the market demand because project owners are essentially demanding higher value projects for lower and lower overall costs, which is achievable, but it requires costly technologies and effort. Finally, this paper attempts to encourage project owners to evaluate their objectives and analyze each delivery system’s effectiveness while considering the decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, which means that successful projects are not only selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind.

Outline

 

  1. Introduction
    • The importance of infrastructure management is the evolution of society, nations, the construction industry, and improvements that it provides
    • Thesis Statement: Most successful project owners consider the possibility of project success rather than only evaluating projects at the outset based while selecting the right delivery system for a massive infrastructure project
  2. Body 1
    • Project delivery systems such and their roles of project delivery systems in large infrastructures
    • Owners challenge in recognizing which delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages are more suitable for their specific project
    • The three fundamental project delivery systems principles
  3. Body 2
    • Challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers
    • In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers
  4. Body 3
    • Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy
    • Nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated
    • Approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects
  5. Conclusion
    • Overall summarize
    • Important considerations
    • Restate thesis statement

 

Articles

 

  1. Garvin, Michael J. “Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement.” Construction Research Congress: Wind of Change: Integration and Innovation. 2003. 1-8. Web.

 

  1. Moore, D. (2000). Selecting the best project delivery system. Paper presented at Project Management Institute Annual Seminars & Symposium, Houston, TX. Newtown Square, PA: Project Management Institute.

 

  1. Knutson, J. (2000). Project Management Infrastructure. PM Network, 14(11), 23–24

 

  1. Foti, R. (2001). Managing Large Construction Projects. PM Network, 15(8), 24–31.

 

  1. Lessard, D. & Miller, R. (2001). Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Library. Sloan Working Paper 4214-01

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Critiques

 

Article 1: Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement

Author: Michael J. Garvin, Ph.D., P.E.

 

Since my initial topic of infrastructural management was too broad, this paper served me as an excellent guide for funneling my ideas. Garvin’s article presents a foundation section that gives statements from earlier authors that reviewed past and current approaches for American infrastructure delivery, development, and application of an operational framework. This section drives me to realize how essential delivery systems are in the industry and how to improve them. This paper also presents a clarification of each delivery system’s characteristics and describes its potential roles in infrastructure improvement by contrasting them by giving a comparison between each delivery system. Gavin also addresses specific case examples that highlight key points and elements of each method. These cases helped me to picture the creation of procurement and contract models that are essentially meant to preserve public interests and to bring the private sector into the participation of the public procurement process. I consider this the way to standardize the procurement and contracting process to maintain transparency and equity in the construction industry. The central or more attractive segment of Gavi’s paper is a comparison table that displays the potential strengths and key factor to take into consideration of each delivery system while performing an infrastructural project. The Key factor segment is the one section I consider more helpful for my research because it explains specific features and circumstances to take into consideration while applying each delivery method. For example, while DB, DBO, or BOT arrangements can provide the contractor flexibility in facility design, owners still have an overarching interest in the safety of public facilities. Finally, Gavin’s presents a future research part that talks about a remarkable Columbia University study that will review procurement strategies and practices where alternative delivery methods were utilized, with specific stress in DBO and O&M.

 

 

 

Article 2: Selecting the Best Project Delivery System.

Author: Dale Moore, PMP, P.E, VP Project Delivery, Shive-Hattery, Inc.

 

I have selected this article from the project management institute because it presents several explanatory graphs that I consider helpful in understanding and interpreting the design and construction industry delivery systems. This paper presents concepts and tools to help owners, design professionals, and the construction industry select and set up a “winning delivery system” for projects. Moore divided his paper into three sections, and each of these sections is divided into three parts. The first section is called the three primary project delivery systems. It also describes the issue of establishing the available project delivery systems used in the United States today can be simplified by first looking at the structure of the relationship and overall responsibility of the performing parties concerning the owner. He also states that the selection of the delivery system should always benefit the owner, but also promote a winning opportunity for all project participants. This is one of the sections where the visual graphs help understand the formation of the relationship. Moreover, Moore explains the three ways systems are structured, single-source, dual-source, and triple source responsibility. The following section is the three key project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper presents seven essential roles needed for all design and construction projects, the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers, and the allocation of risk for winning projects. Therefore, design professionals and the construction industry have the opportunity to lead owners through the project delivery selection process and help the owner fill the seven essential roles. And also, Moore’s article describes the efficiency of assigning a responsible party to each of these roles. The final section is the three key areas of consideration for project delivery system selection, which are project, owner, and team-building.

 

 

Article 3: Project Management Infrastructure

Author: Knutson, Joan. President of PMSI-Project Mentors

 

This paper helped me to set my mind on the importance of a robust and reliable infrastructure from the perspective of project management. Knutson says that infrastructure is the basis, underlying framework, or features of an organization or system. And as any foundation, it requires a framework made up of products, people, processes, and platforms inside an organization. For the most part, project management infrastructure consists of systems of policies, standards, procedures, and guidelines that define how project management work is to be performed. However, Joan suggests that four fundamental elements are part of a project management framework or infrastructure. Her first element is the portfolio management system (the product). This element ensures the initiation of the project management process based on a solid strategic business decision restricted by five sub-processes: solicitation, selection, prioritization, registration, and enterprise resource planning process. Knutson describes the five sub-processes by employing her own words, which I found helpful; she described them as doing the right projects, stopping the wrong ones, doing them in the right order, codifying them in a central repository, and staffing them with the right people. This part of the infrastructure allows the enterprise to manage the inventory of projects within the enterprise. The following process is a managing system (the process) that essentially takes the approved and prioritized project into the definition, planning, execution, control, and closeout phases. Knutson describes the life cycle of a project by explaining the phases, while she defines it as the discipline of project management performed consistently and professionally throughout the organization. The next process is the organizational management system (the platform). This article described as the governance structure, defining roles, responsibilities, and authorities and reporting relationships that indicate the political interactions between departments and people within the project community. And the final process is the performance management system (the people), which essentially supports the other three systems described above.

 

 

 

Article 4: Managing Large Construction Projects

Author: Foti, Ross

 

This paper was the one that gave me the view I was looking for in my final paper: the essence of large infrastructural projects. This article discusses different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers, such as significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. Foti emphasizes communication planning and management utilizing real-life examples that illustrate the importance and consequences of the appropriate procedures, quality control processes, and schedules, in both large and small projects. Moreover, it exposes the importance of time management. One of the quotes that attracted my attention was “The people doing the work can have tunnel vision, it’s hard for them to have a big-picture view of the schedule and what must be done to maintain the schedule,” Blakemore. Even though it is true, I believe there are other important reasons why it could be hard for people to have a big picture view of the schedule, such as mobile distractions and unplanned communication. The next section of the paper is quality concerns. Here the author implies that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. It also points out that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. For this reason, I understand that excellent communication management with the project team, stakeholders, and owners is essential to preserve quality throughout the project lifecycle. Next in this article is construction risks, here Foti states that initiation is a problematic section of large construction because of how broad scope definition and project planning are, which regularly affects the quality of the deliverable. It also covers some recommendations in following the WBS closely, committing to a dedicated and accountable scheduler, coordinating the convergence of people and materials, using language standards in large projects, and presenting realistic delivery dates.

 

 

 

 

Article 5: Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects

Author: Donald Lessard and Roger Miller

 

This paper from MIT Sloan School of Management called my attention because the principal argument developed is that successful projects are not selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind. Rather than evaluating projects at the outset based on projections of the full sets of benefits, costs, and risks over their lifetime, successful sponsors start with project ideas that might become viable. This argument presents a different point of view that I consider quite interesting because it is mainly based on a possibility instead of a projection. Indeed, Donald and Roger hold that successful firms cut their losses quickly when they recognize that a project has little chance of becoming viable. Another interesting quote from this paper is that “the seeds of success or failure are thus planted and nurtured as conscious choices are made.” Therefore, this project presents a section that refers to a risk-based taxonomy of large engineering projects where the author illustrates how risks differ according to types of projects. They utilize a graph to demonstrate how institutional risk varies from projects depending on how far they are of the public attention and their social acceptability. Moreover, it explains the nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated. It also explains market-related, completion, and institutional risks, which are other that can occur due to external and internal factors. Next is the section why I mainly selected this paper, the approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects. Here Donald and Roger differentiate risk management within two broad categories of approaches. The first one is decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, this category landscape projects as gambles in which sponsors try to identify options and probabilities. In other words, administrators select a move with a high payoff, make a bet, and wait for the chances to materialize. And the other one is managerial approaches that understand that risk depends on the interaction between exogenous risk drivers and the shaping of risk drivers throughout the process.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Role of Delivery Systems in Large Infrastructure Projects

Bruno Sanchez

Northeastern University

 

 

 

 

 

Abstract

 

 

Infrastructure management has always been important for the evolution of society, nations, and construction in general because the infrastructure projects are the improvements that provide the necessary assets, systems, and networks that countries require to grow. However, without proper management and delivery system, infrastructure projects would not be achievable. Several delivery systems can be used on construction projects. This paper will focus on the more popular ones. Project delivery systems such as construction management at risk, design-bid-build, design-build, progressive design-build, and multi-prime contracts offer project owners different options for value in infrastructure cost, quality, service, and technology. Delivery systems also connect to the owners’ approach in planning and organizing the project team that will manage the design and construction. This paper aims to identify the role of project delivery systems in large infrastructures. Moreover, interpreting the more practiced delivery system in the industry, their characteristics, and their potential role in infrastructure improvement. Since infrastructural projects always bring significant challenges due to their massive levels of uncertainty, complexity, and notorious costs and time overruns, it is common to see these projects miss in completing their original goals. Therefore, it will assist project owners in recognizing how project delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages assist in mitigating and mastering these challenges, considering that every project is different, and owners’ objectives vary from one to another.

 

 

This paper will also incorporate the three fundamental project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers. It will describe the different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers. Challenges include significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. The paper covers quality concerns of large infrastructural projects, pointing out that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. Its disposition is to explain that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy. It is even more challenging to meet the market demand because project owners are essentially demanding higher value projects for lower and lower overall costs, which is achievable, but it requires costly technologies and effort. Finally, this paper attempts to encourage project owners to evaluate their objectives and analyze each delivery system’s effectiveness while considering the decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, which means that successful projects are not only selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind.

Outline

 

  1. Introduction
    • The importance of infrastructure management is the evolution of society, nations, the construction industry, and improvements that it provides
    • Thesis Statement: Most successful project owners consider the possibility of project success rather than only evaluating projects at the outset based while selecting the right delivery system for a massive infrastructure project
  2. Body 1
    • Project delivery systems such and their roles of project delivery systems in large infrastructures
    • Owners challenge in recognizing which delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages are more suitable for their specific project
    • The three fundamental project delivery systems principles
  3. Body 2
    • Challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers
    • In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers
  4. Body 3
    • Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy
    • Nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated
    • Approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects
  5. Conclusion
    • Overall summarize
    • Important considerations
    • Restate thesis statement

 

Articles

 

  1. Garvin, Michael J. “Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement.” Construction Research Congress: Wind of Change: Integration and Innovation. 2003. 1-8. Web.

 

  1. Moore, D. (2000). Selecting the best project delivery system. Paper presented at Project Management Institute Annual Seminars & Symposium, Houston, TX. Newtown Square, PA: Project Management Institute.

 

  1. Knutson, J. (2000). Project Management Infrastructure. PM Network, 14(11), 23–24

 

  1. Foti, R. (2001). Managing Large Construction Projects. PM Network, 15(8), 24–31.

 

  1. Lessard, D. & Miller, R. (2001). Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Library. Sloan Working Paper 4214-01

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Critiques

 

Article 1: Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement

Author: Michael J. Garvin, Ph.D., P.E.

 

Since my initial topic of infrastructural management was too broad, this paper served me as an excellent guide for funneling my ideas. Garvin’s article presents a foundation section that gives statements from earlier authors that reviewed past and current approaches for American infrastructure delivery, development, and application of an operational framework. This section drives me to realize how essential delivery systems are in the industry and how to improve them. This paper also presents a clarification of each delivery system’s characteristics and describes its potential roles in infrastructure improvement by contrasting them by giving a comparison between each delivery system. Gavin also addresses specific case examples that highlight key points and elements of each method. These cases helped me to picture the creation of procurement and contract models that are essentially meant to preserve public interests and to bring the private sector into the participation of the public procurement process. I consider this the way to standardize the procurement and contracting process to maintain transparency and equity in the construction industry. The central or more attractive segment of Gavi’s paper is a comparison table that displays the potential strengths and key factor to take into consideration of each delivery system while performing an infrastructural project. The Key factor segment is the one section I consider more helpful for my research because it explains specific features and circumstances to take into consideration while applying each delivery method. For example, while DB, DBO, or BOT arrangements can provide the contractor flexibility in facility design, owners still have an overarching interest in the safety of public facilities. Finally, Gavin’s presents a future research part that talks about a remarkable Columbia University study that will review procurement strategies and practices where alternative delivery methods were utilized, with specific stress in DBO and O&M.

 

 

 

Article 2: Selecting the Best Project Delivery System.

Author: Dale Moore, PMP, P.E, VP Project Delivery, Shive-Hattery, Inc.

 

I have selected this article from the project management institute because it presents several explanatory graphs that I consider helpful in understanding and interpreting the design and construction industry delivery systems. This paper presents concepts and tools to help owners, design professionals, and the construction industry select and set up a “winning delivery system” for projects. Moore divided his paper into three sections, and each of these sections is divided into three parts. The first section is called the three primary project delivery systems. It also describes the issue of establishing the available project delivery systems used in the United States today can be simplified by first looking at the structure of the relationship and overall responsibility of the performing parties concerning the owner. He also states that the selection of the delivery system should always benefit the owner, but also promote a winning opportunity for all project participants. This is one of the sections where the visual graphs help understand the formation of the relationship. Moreover, Moore explains the three ways systems are structured, single-source, dual-source, and triple source responsibility. The following section is the three key project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper presents seven essential roles needed for all design and construction projects, the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers, and the allocation of risk for winning projects. Therefore, design professionals and the construction industry have the opportunity to lead owners through the project delivery selection process and help the owner fill the seven essential roles. And also, Moore’s article describes the efficiency of assigning a responsible party to each of these roles. The final section is the three key areas of consideration for project delivery system selection, which are project, owner, and team-building.

 

 

Article 3: Project Management Infrastructure

Author: Knutson, Joan. President of PMSI-Project Mentors

 

This paper helped me to set my mind on the importance of a robust and reliable infrastructure from the perspective of project management. Knutson says that infrastructure is the basis, underlying framework, or features of an organization or system. And as any foundation, it requires a framework made up of products, people, processes, and platforms inside an organization. For the most part, project management infrastructure consists of systems of policies, standards, procedures, and guidelines that define how project management work is to be performed. However, Joan suggests that four fundamental elements are part of a project management framework or infrastructure. Her first element is the portfolio management system (the product). This element ensures the initiation of the project management process based on a solid strategic business decision restricted by five sub-processes: solicitation, selection, prioritization, registration, and enterprise resource planning process. Knutson describes the five sub-processes by employing her own words, which I found helpful; she described them as doing the right projects, stopping the wrong ones, doing them in the right order, codifying them in a central repository, and staffing them with the right people. This part of the infrastructure allows the enterprise to manage the inventory of projects within the enterprise. The following process is a managing system (the process) that essentially takes the approved and prioritized project into the definition, planning, execution, control, and closeout phases. Knutson describes the life cycle of a project by explaining the phases, while she defines it as the discipline of project management performed consistently and professionally throughout the organization. The next process is the organizational management system (the platform). This article described as the governance structure, defining roles, responsibilities, and authorities and reporting relationships that indicate the political interactions between departments and people within the project community. And the final process is the performance management system (the people), which essentially supports the other three systems described above.

 

 

 

Article 4: Managing Large Construction Projects

Author: Foti, Ross

 

This paper was the one that gave me the view I was looking for in my final paper: the essence of large infrastructural projects. This article discusses different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers, such as significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. Foti emphasizes communication planning and management utilizing real-life examples that illustrate the importance and consequences of the appropriate procedures, quality control processes, and schedules, in both large and small projects. Moreover, it exposes the importance of time management. One of the quotes that attracted my attention was “The people doing the work can have tunnel vision, it’s hard for them to have a big-picture view of the schedule and what must be done to maintain the schedule,” Blakemore. Even though it is true, I believe there are other important reasons why it could be hard for people to have a big picture view of the schedule, such as mobile distractions and unplanned communication. The next section of the paper is quality concerns. Here the author implies that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. It also points out that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. For this reason, I understand that excellent communication management with the project team, stakeholders, and owners is essential to preserve quality throughout the project lifecycle. Next in this article is construction risks, here Foti states that initiation is a problematic section of large construction because of how broad scope definition and project planning are, which regularly affects the quality of the deliverable. It also covers some recommendations in following the WBS closely, committing to a dedicated and accountable scheduler, coordinating the convergence of people and materials, using language standards in large projects, and presenting realistic delivery dates.

 

 

 

 

Article 5: Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects

Author: Donald Lessard and Roger Miller

 

This paper from MIT Sloan School of Management called my attention because the principal argument developed is that successful projects are not selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind. Rather than evaluating projects at the outset based on projections of the full sets of benefits, costs, and risks over their lifetime, successful sponsors start with project ideas that might become viable. This argument presents a different point of view that I consider quite interesting because it is mainly based on a possibility instead of a projection. Indeed, Donald and Roger hold that successful firms cut their losses quickly when they recognize that a project has little chance of becoming viable. Another interesting quote from this paper is that “the seeds of success or failure are thus planted and nurtured as conscious choices are made.” Therefore, this project presents a section that refers to a risk-based taxonomy of large engineering projects where the author illustrates how risks differ according to types of projects. They utilize a graph to demonstrate how institutional risk varies from projects depending on how far they are of the public attention and their social acceptability. Moreover, it explains the nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated. It also explains market-related, completion, and institutional risks, which are other that can occur due to external and internal factors. Next is the section why I mainly selected this paper, the approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects. Here Donald and Roger differentiate risk management within two broad categories of approaches. The first one is decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, this category landscape projects as gambles in which sponsors try to identify options and probabilities. In other words, administrators select a move with a high payoff, make a bet, and wait for the chances to materialize. And the other one is managerial approaches that understand that risk depends on the interaction between exogenous risk drivers and the shaping of risk drivers throughout the process.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Role of Delivery Systems in Large Infrastructure Projects

Bruno Sanchez

Northeastern University

 

 

 

 

 

Abstract

 

 

Infrastructure management has always been important for the evolution of society, nations, and construction in general because the infrastructure projects are the improvements that provide the necessary assets, systems, and networks that countries require to grow. However, without proper management and delivery system, infrastructure projects would not be achievable. Several delivery systems can be used on construction projects. This paper will focus on the more popular ones. Project delivery systems such as construction management at risk, design-bid-build, design-build, progressive design-build, and multi-prime contracts offer project owners different options for value in infrastructure cost, quality, service, and technology. Delivery systems also connect to the owners’ approach in planning and organizing the project team that will manage the design and construction. This paper aims to identify the role of project delivery systems in large infrastructures. Moreover, interpreting the more practiced delivery system in the industry, their characteristics, and their potential role in infrastructure improvement. Since infrastructural projects always bring significant challenges due to their massive levels of uncertainty, complexity, and notorious costs and time overruns, it is common to see these projects miss in completing their original goals. Therefore, it will assist project owners in recognizing how project delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages assist in mitigating and mastering these challenges, considering that every project is different, and owners’ objectives vary from one to another.

 

 

This paper will also incorporate the three fundamental project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers. It will describe the different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers. Challenges include significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. The paper covers quality concerns of large infrastructural projects, pointing out that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. Its disposition is to explain that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy. It is even more challenging to meet the market demand because project owners are essentially demanding higher value projects for lower and lower overall costs, which is achievable, but it requires costly technologies and effort. Finally, this paper attempts to encourage project owners to evaluate their objectives and analyze each delivery system’s effectiveness while considering the decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, which means that successful projects are not only selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind.

Outline

 

  1. Introduction
    • The importance of infrastructure management is the evolution of society, nations, the construction industry, and improvements that it provides
    • Thesis Statement: Most successful project owners consider the possibility of project success rather than only evaluating projects at the outset based while selecting the right delivery system for a massive infrastructure project
  2. Body 1
    • Project delivery systems such and their roles of project delivery systems in large infrastructures
    • Owners challenge in recognizing which delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages are more suitable for their specific project
    • The three fundamental project delivery systems principles
  3. Body 2
    • Challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers
    • In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers
  4. Body 3
    • Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy
    • Nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated
    • Approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects
  5. Conclusion
    • Overall summarize
    • Important considerations
    • Restate thesis statement

 

Articles

 

  1. Garvin, Michael J. “Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement.” Construction Research Congress: Wind of Change: Integration and Innovation. 2003. 1-8. Web.

 

  1. Moore, D. (2000). Selecting the best project delivery system. Paper presented at Project Management Institute Annual Seminars & Symposium, Houston, TX. Newtown Square, PA: Project Management Institute.

 

  1. Knutson, J. (2000). Project Management Infrastructure. PM Network, 14(11), 23–24

 

  1. Foti, R. (2001). Managing Large Construction Projects. PM Network, 15(8), 24–31.

 

  1. Lessard, D. & Miller, R. (2001). Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Library. Sloan Working Paper 4214-01

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Critiques

 

Article 1: Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement

Author: Michael J. Garvin, Ph.D., P.E.

 

Since my initial topic of infrastructural management was too broad, this paper served me as an excellent guide for funneling my ideas. Garvin’s article presents a foundation section that gives statements from earlier authors that reviewed past and current approaches for American infrastructure delivery, development, and application of an operational framework. This section drives me to realize how essential delivery systems are in the industry and how to improve them. This paper also presents a clarification of each delivery system’s characteristics and describes its potential roles in infrastructure improvement by contrasting them by giving a comparison between each delivery system. Gavin also addresses specific case examples that highlight key points and elements of each method. These cases helped me to picture the creation of procurement and contract models that are essentially meant to preserve public interests and to bring the private sector into the participation of the public procurement process. I consider this the way to standardize the procurement and contracting process to maintain transparency and equity in the construction industry. The central or more attractive segment of Gavi’s paper is a comparison table that displays the potential strengths and key factor to take into consideration of each delivery system while performing an infrastructural project. The Key factor segment is the one section I consider more helpful for my research because it explains specific features and circumstances to take into consideration while applying each delivery method. For example, while DB, DBO, or BOT arrangements can provide the contractor flexibility in facility design, owners still have an overarching interest in the safety of public facilities. Finally, Gavin’s presents a future research part that talks about a remarkable Columbia University study that will review procurement strategies and practices where alternative delivery methods were utilized, with specific stress in DBO and O&M.

 

 

 

Article 2: Selecting the Best Project Delivery System.

Author: Dale Moore, PMP, P.E, VP Project Delivery, Shive-Hattery, Inc.

 

I have selected this article from the project management institute because it presents several explanatory graphs that I consider helpful in understanding and interpreting the design and construction industry delivery systems. This paper presents concepts and tools to help owners, design professionals, and the construction industry select and set up a “winning delivery system” for projects. Moore divided his paper into three sections, and each of these sections is divided into three parts. The first section is called the three primary project delivery systems. It also describes the issue of establishing the available project delivery systems used in the United States today can be simplified by first looking at the structure of the relationship and overall responsibility of the performing parties concerning the owner. He also states that the selection of the delivery system should always benefit the owner, but also promote a winning opportunity for all project participants. This is one of the sections where the visual graphs help understand the formation of the relationship. Moreover, Moore explains the three ways systems are structured, single-source, dual-source, and triple source responsibility. The following section is the three key project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper presents seven essential roles needed for all design and construction projects, the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers, and the allocation of risk for winning projects. Therefore, design professionals and the construction industry have the opportunity to lead owners through the project delivery selection process and help the owner fill the seven essential roles. And also, Moore’s article describes the efficiency of assigning a responsible party to each of these roles. The final section is the three key areas of consideration for project delivery system selection, which are project, owner, and team-building.

 

 

Article 3: Project Management Infrastructure

Author: Knutson, Joan. President of PMSI-Project Mentors

 

This paper helped me to set my mind on the importance of a robust and reliable infrastructure from the perspective of project management. Knutson says that infrastructure is the basis, underlying framework, or features of an organization or system. And as any foundation, it requires a framework made up of products, people, processes, and platforms inside an organization. For the most part, project management infrastructure consists of systems of policies, standards, procedures, and guidelines that define how project management work is to be performed. However, Joan suggests that four fundamental elements are part of a project management framework or infrastructure. Her first element is the portfolio management system (the product). This element ensures the initiation of the project management process based on a solid strategic business decision restricted by five sub-processes: solicitation, selection, prioritization, registration, and enterprise resource planning process. Knutson describes the five sub-processes by employing her own words, which I found helpful; she described them as doing the right projects, stopping the wrong ones, doing them in the right order, codifying them in a central repository, and staffing them with the right people. This part of the infrastructure allows the enterprise to manage the inventory of projects within the enterprise. The following process is a managing system (the process) that essentially takes the approved and prioritized project into the definition, planning, execution, control, and closeout phases. Knutson describes the life cycle of a project by explaining the phases, while she defines it as the discipline of project management performed consistently and professionally throughout the organization. The next process is the organizational management system (the platform). This article described as the governance structure, defining roles, responsibilities, and authorities and reporting relationships that indicate the political interactions between departments and people within the project community. And the final process is the performance management system (the people), which essentially supports the other three systems described above.

 

 

 

Article 4: Managing Large Construction Projects

Author: Foti, Ross

 

This paper was the one that gave me the view I was looking for in my final paper: the essence of large infrastructural projects. This article discusses different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers, such as significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. Foti emphasizes communication planning and management utilizing real-life examples that illustrate the importance and consequences of the appropriate procedures, quality control processes, and schedules, in both large and small projects. Moreover, it exposes the importance of time management. One of the quotes that attracted my attention was “The people doing the work can have tunnel vision, it’s hard for them to have a big-picture view of the schedule and what must be done to maintain the schedule,” Blakemore. Even though it is true, I believe there are other important reasons why it could be hard for people to have a big picture view of the schedule, such as mobile distractions and unplanned communication. The next section of the paper is quality concerns. Here the author implies that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. It also points out that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. For this reason, I understand that excellent communication management with the project team, stakeholders, and owners is essential to preserve quality throughout the project lifecycle. Next in this article is construction risks, here Foti states that initiation is a problematic section of large construction because of how broad scope definition and project planning are, which regularly affects the quality of the deliverable. It also covers some recommendations in following the WBS closely, committing to a dedicated and accountable scheduler, coordinating the convergence of people and materials, using language standards in large projects, and presenting realistic delivery dates.

 

 

 

 

Article 5: Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects

Author: Donald Lessard and Roger Miller

 

This paper from MIT Sloan School of Management called my attention because the principal argument developed is that successful projects are not selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind. Rather than evaluating projects at the outset based on projections of the full sets of benefits, costs, and risks over their lifetime, successful sponsors start with project ideas that might become viable. This argument presents a different point of view that I consider quite interesting because it is mainly based on a possibility instead of a projection. Indeed, Donald and Roger hold that successful firms cut their losses quickly when they recognize that a project has little chance of becoming viable. Another interesting quote from this paper is that “the seeds of success or failure are thus planted and nurtured as conscious choices are made.” Therefore, this project presents a section that refers to a risk-based taxonomy of large engineering projects where the author illustrates how risks differ according to types of projects. They utilize a graph to demonstrate how institutional risk varies from projects depending on how far they are of the public attention and their social acceptability. Moreover, it explains the nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated. It also explains market-related, completion, and institutional risks, which are other that can occur due to external and internal factors. Next is the section why I mainly selected this paper, the approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects. Here Donald and Roger differentiate risk management within two broad categories of approaches. The first one is decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, this category landscape projects as gambles in which sponsors try to identify options and probabilities. In other words, administrators select a move with a high payoff, make a bet, and wait for the chances to materialize. And the other one is managerial approaches that understand that risk depends on the interaction between exogenous risk drivers and the shaping of risk drivers throughout the process.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Role of Delivery Systems in Large Infrastructure Projects

Bruno Sanchez

Northeastern University

 

 

 

 

 

Abstract

 

 

Infrastructure management has always been important for the evolution of society, nations, and construction in general because the infrastructure projects are the improvements that provide the necessary assets, systems, and networks that countries require to grow. However, without proper management and delivery system, infrastructure projects would not be achievable. Several delivery systems can be used on construction projects. This paper will focus on the more popular ones. Project delivery systems such as construction management at risk, design-bid-build, design-build, progressive design-build, and multi-prime contracts offer project owners different options for value in infrastructure cost, quality, service, and technology. Delivery systems also connect to the owners’ approach in planning and organizing the project team that will manage the design and construction. This paper aims to identify the role of project delivery systems in large infrastructures. Moreover, interpreting the more practiced delivery system in the industry, their characteristics, and their potential role in infrastructure improvement. Since infrastructural projects always bring significant challenges due to their massive levels of uncertainty, complexity, and notorious costs and time overruns, it is common to see these projects miss in completing their original goals. Therefore, it will assist project owners in recognizing how project delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages assist in mitigating and mastering these challenges, considering that every project is different, and owners’ objectives vary from one to another.

 

 

This paper will also incorporate the three fundamental project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers. It will describe the different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers. Challenges include significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. The paper covers quality concerns of large infrastructural projects, pointing out that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. Its disposition is to explain that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy. It is even more challenging to meet the market demand because project owners are essentially demanding higher value projects for lower and lower overall costs, which is achievable, but it requires costly technologies and effort. Finally, this paper attempts to encourage project owners to evaluate their objectives and analyze each delivery system’s effectiveness while considering the decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, which means that successful projects are not only selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind.

Outline

 

  1. Introduction
    • The importance of infrastructure management is the evolution of society, nations, the construction industry, and improvements that it provides
    • Thesis Statement: Most successful project owners consider the possibility of project success rather than only evaluating projects at the outset based while selecting the right delivery system for a massive infrastructure project
  2. Body 1
    • Project delivery systems such and their roles of project delivery systems in large infrastructures
    • Owners challenge in recognizing which delivery systems’ advantages and disadvantages are more suitable for their specific project
    • The three fundamental project delivery systems principles
  3. Body 2
    • Challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers
    • In this section, the paper also presents essential roles needed for all design and construction projects and the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers
  4. Body 3
    • Infrastructure projects are facing a large number of challenges due to today’s rushed and complicated pace of the economy
    • Nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated
    • Approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects
  5. Conclusion
    • Overall summarize
    • Important considerations
    • Restate thesis statement

 

Articles

 

  1. Garvin, Michael J. “Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement.” Construction Research Congress: Wind of Change: Integration and Innovation. 2003. 1-8. Web.

 

  1. Moore, D. (2000). Selecting the best project delivery system. Paper presented at Project Management Institute Annual Seminars & Symposium, Houston, TX. Newtown Square, PA: Project Management Institute.

 

  1. Knutson, J. (2000). Project Management Infrastructure. PM Network, 14(11), 23–24

 

  1. Foti, R. (2001). Managing Large Construction Projects. PM Network, 15(8), 24–31.

 

  1. Lessard, D. & Miller, R. (2001). Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Library. Sloan Working Paper 4214-01

 

 

 

 

 

Articles Critiques

 

Article 1: Role of Project Delivery Systems in Infrastructure Improvement

Author: Michael J. Garvin, Ph.D., P.E.

 

Since my initial topic of infrastructural management was too broad, this paper served me as an excellent guide for funneling my ideas. Garvin’s article presents a foundation section that gives statements from earlier authors that reviewed past and current approaches for American infrastructure delivery, development, and application of an operational framework. This section drives me to realize how essential delivery systems are in the industry and how to improve them. This paper also presents a clarification of each delivery system’s characteristics and describes its potential roles in infrastructure improvement by contrasting them by giving a comparison between each delivery system. Gavin also addresses specific case examples that highlight key points and elements of each method. These cases helped me to picture the creation of procurement and contract models that are essentially meant to preserve public interests and to bring the private sector into the participation of the public procurement process. I consider this the way to standardize the procurement and contracting process to maintain transparency and equity in the construction industry. The central or more attractive segment of Gavi’s paper is a comparison table that displays the potential strengths and key factor to take into consideration of each delivery system while performing an infrastructural project. The Key factor segment is the one section I consider more helpful for my research because it explains specific features and circumstances to take into consideration while applying each delivery method. For example, while DB, DBO, or BOT arrangements can provide the contractor flexibility in facility design, owners still have an overarching interest in the safety of public facilities. Finally, Gavin’s presents a future research part that talks about a remarkable Columbia University study that will review procurement strategies and practices where alternative delivery methods were utilized, with specific stress in DBO and O&M.

 

 

 

Article 2: Selecting the Best Project Delivery System.

Author: Dale Moore, PMP, P.E, VP Project Delivery, Shive-Hattery, Inc.

 

I have selected this article from the project management institute because it presents several explanatory graphs that I consider helpful in understanding and interpreting the design and construction industry delivery systems. This paper presents concepts and tools to help owners, design professionals, and the construction industry select and set up a “winning delivery system” for projects. Moore divided his paper into three sections, and each of these sections is divided into three parts. The first section is called the three primary project delivery systems. It also describes the issue of establishing the available project delivery systems used in the United States today can be simplified by first looking at the structure of the relationship and overall responsibility of the performing parties concerning the owner. He also states that the selection of the delivery system should always benefit the owner, but also promote a winning opportunity for all project participants. This is one of the sections where the visual graphs help understand the formation of the relationship. Moreover, Moore explains the three ways systems are structured, single-source, dual-source, and triple source responsibility. The following section is the three key project delivery systems principles. In this section, the paper presents seven essential roles needed for all design and construction projects, the two types of agreements that owners hold with the design and construction providers, and the allocation of risk for winning projects. Therefore, design professionals and the construction industry have the opportunity to lead owners through the project delivery selection process and help the owner fill the seven essential roles. And also, Moore’s article describes the efficiency of assigning a responsible party to each of these roles. The final section is the three key areas of consideration for project delivery system selection, which are project, owner, and team-building.

 

 

Article 3: Project Management Infrastructure

Author: Knutson, Joan. President of PMSI-Project Mentors

 

This paper helped me to set my mind on the importance of a robust and reliable infrastructure from the perspective of project management. Knutson says that infrastructure is the basis, underlying framework, or features of an organization or system. And as any foundation, it requires a framework made up of products, people, processes, and platforms inside an organization. For the most part, project management infrastructure consists of systems of policies, standards, procedures, and guidelines that define how project management work is to be performed. However, Joan suggests that four fundamental elements are part of a project management framework or infrastructure. Her first element is the portfolio management system (the product). This element ensures the initiation of the project management process based on a solid strategic business decision restricted by five sub-processes: solicitation, selection, prioritization, registration, and enterprise resource planning process. Knutson describes the five sub-processes by employing her own words, which I found helpful; she described them as doing the right projects, stopping the wrong ones, doing them in the right order, codifying them in a central repository, and staffing them with the right people. This part of the infrastructure allows the enterprise to manage the inventory of projects within the enterprise. The following process is a managing system (the process) that essentially takes the approved and prioritized project into the definition, planning, execution, control, and closeout phases. Knutson describes the life cycle of a project by explaining the phases, while she defines it as the discipline of project management performed consistently and professionally throughout the organization. The next process is the organizational management system (the platform). This article described as the governance structure, defining roles, responsibilities, and authorities and reporting relationships that indicate the political interactions between departments and people within the project community. And the final process is the performance management system (the people), which essentially supports the other three systems described above.

 

 

 

Article 4: Managing Large Construction Projects

Author: Foti, Ross

 

This paper was the one that gave me the view I was looking for in my final paper: the essence of large infrastructural projects. This article discusses different challenges that large construction projects hold to project managers, such as significant lead times, distribution of risks among quality specialists, safety, and dealing with scope creep. Foti emphasizes communication planning and management utilizing real-life examples that illustrate the importance and consequences of the appropriate procedures, quality control processes, and schedules, in both large and small projects. Moreover, it exposes the importance of time management. One of the quotes that attracted my attention was “The people doing the work can have tunnel vision, it’s hard for them to have a big-picture view of the schedule and what must be done to maintain the schedule,” Blakemore. Even though it is true, I believe there are other important reasons why it could be hard for people to have a big picture view of the schedule, such as mobile distractions and unplanned communication. The next section of the paper is quality concerns. Here the author implies that the larger the project, the more experts will be needed. It also points out that quality is often difficult to define because what is quality to one is not up for another, and communication of objectives remains pivotal. For this reason, I understand that excellent communication management with the project team, stakeholders, and owners is essential to preserve quality throughout the project lifecycle. Next in this article is construction risks, here Foti states that initiation is a problematic section of large construction because of how broad scope definition and project planning are, which regularly affects the quality of the deliverable. It also covers some recommendations in following the WBS closely, committing to a dedicated and accountable scheduler, coordinating the convergence of people and materials, using language standards in large projects, and presenting realistic delivery dates.

 

 

 

 

Article 5: Understanding and Managing Risks in Large Engineering Projects

Author: Donald Lessard and Roger Miller

 

This paper from MIT Sloan School of Management called my attention because the principal argument developed is that successful projects are not selected but shaped with risk resolution in mind. Rather than evaluating projects at the outset based on projections of the full sets of benefits, costs, and risks over their lifetime, successful sponsors start with project ideas that might become viable. This argument presents a different point of view that I consider quite interesting because it is mainly based on a possibility instead of a projection. Indeed, Donald and Roger hold that successful firms cut their losses quickly when they recognize that a project has little chance of becoming viable. Another interesting quote from this paper is that “the seeds of success or failure are thus planted and nurtured as conscious choices are made.” Therefore, this project presents a section that refers to a risk-based taxonomy of large engineering projects where the author illustrates how risks differ according to types of projects. They utilize a graph to demonstrate how institutional risk varies from projects depending on how far they are of the public attention and their social acceptability. Moreover, it explains the nature of risks in projects as the possibility that events, their resulting impacts, and dynamic interactions may turn out differently than anticipated. It also explains market-related, completion, and institutional risks, which are other that can occur due to external and internal factors. Next is the section why I mainly selected this paper, the approaches to managing risk in large engineering projects. Here Donald and Roger differentiate risk management within two broad categories of approaches. The first one is decision-theoretic approaches that assume that risks are exogenous, this category landscape projects as gambles in which sponsors try to identify options and probabilities. In other words, administrators select a move with a high payoff, make a bet, and wait for the chances to materialize. And the other one is managerial approaches that understand that risk depends on the interaction between exogenous risk drivers and the shaping of risk drivers throughout the process.

Suzie Mercy

Recent Posts

What is the easy difination of science | Quick Solution

Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social…

4 years ago

definition, values, meaning of such values and type of goods with such elasticity value …….. | Quick Solution

Clearly stating the definition, the values, the meaning of such values and the type of…

4 years ago

Acct 422 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago

Acct 322 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago

Macro Economics Question | Quick Solution

https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/04/25/605092520/high-paying-trade-jobs-sit-empty-while-high-school-grads-line-up-for-university Click on the link above. Read the entire link and answer the questions below…

4 years ago

MGT 322 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago