If the exact wording of the judgment is included anywhere in your brief it must be in quotation marks and the paragraph where it is taken from must be identified e.g., (para. 23).
This handout contains the criteria for the case brief assignment. Each case brief assignment is based on a specific legal case chosen by the instructor. These cases will be posted on our course website. Check with the instructor if you are unsure of the case you should be briefing. The case brief must be typed, double-spaced and should not exceed 4 double-spaced pages excluding your cover page. You must use proper sentences. Point form is not acceptable. Your writing (e.g., grammar, spelling, comprehension and flow) will be considered when grading this assignment. You must include a cover sheet stapled to the front of the assignment indicating your name, student number and the name of the assignment.
When writing your case brief, remember it is intended to be a brief overview or summary of the judicial ruling. It is your task to communicate all the essential information the reader needs to understand the significance of the case without the necessity of reading the entire decision. Do NOT paraphrase the decision line for line or provide endless quotations since the reader might just as well read the original case. Use the headings identified in class to organize your writing (see the suggested formatting at the end of the handout). In addition to your writing and organization, the case brief will be graded on the quality and accuracy of the following required components:
A. Citation
Use proper legal citation to identify the case.
B. Facts
Identify the parties and explain their relationship to one another (e.g., the plaintiff was injured at the defendant’s swimming pool). Next, outline the relevant facts. Put differently, describe all the facts the reader needs to understand the issues, reasoning and ratio of the case. Generally speaking the facts describe events or circumstances before legal proceedings were commenced. Oftentimes the parties provide different versions of what happened in the case, but the facts are what the court decided actually occurred.
C. Procedural history
The procedural history describes the legal processes and previous decisions of the courts in the case. If it is the first time the case has come to court, describe the nature of the current legal proceeding including who initiated the proceeding, the nature of the proceeding, and the level of court (e.g., the Crown is prosecuting the accused for sexual assault in BC Supreme Court). If there is no mention of any prior legal proceedings in the decision then it is generally safe to assume this is the first time the case has come to court. If the case is being appealed, for each previous level of court describe in a sentence or two (a) party that commenced the proceeding, (b) the nature of the proceeding (e.g., A sued B for negligence, B applied to dismiss the action); (c) the level of court (e.g., in BC Supreme Court), (d) identify the successful party.
D. Issue(s)
Identify the central question(s) that the court is being asked to answer (i.e., what is in dispute?). Number each issue and state it in the form of a question. Each issue should be put on a separate line.
E. Decision
Describe the ruling of the court with a brief “yes” or “no” statement for each issue you identified (e.g., “Yes, the contract was binding”). At the end of this section, indicate the overall result in the case (e.g., appeal allowed, costs to the plaintiff).
F. Reasoning
Provide a summary of the court’s reasoning for its judgment in the case. In other words, outline the court’s stated explanation and logic for arriving at its decision on each issue. Where more than one issue exists, identify each one with a subheading (e.g., “Issue #1:__”) and summarize the reasoning that relates to it. If you are summarizing an appellate decision where more than one judge has written an opinion, identify each opinion with a subheading, summarize the reasoning relating to that opinion and indicate whether it constitutes the majority, the dissent, or if it concurs with the majority.
D. Lyon © 2017
G. Ratio
Identify the legal principle(s) that emerge from the case. This is perhaps the most challenging part of the case brief. You need to briefly articulate a legal rule based on the way the court decided the issue(s) in the case. Where more than one issue exists, there is typically more than one ratio. To state the ratio or legal rule link the important facts of the case to the court’s decision [e.g., in these factual circumstances (a skier who signed a form she knew was a liability waiver) ….this was the result (she could not recover damages for injuries she suffered at the ski resort)]. Ratios should be stated in a single sentence and as succinctly and accurately as possible. You need to provide at least one specific and one general ratio.
You may consult headnotes to assist with your understanding of the case, but do not rely on these. You will need to read and understand the case yourself in order to properly complete the case brief. If you need background material to better understand the issues and decision in the case you should consult a legal text. If you are unsure about the case citation please refer to your class notes or consult the Canadian Guide to Uniform Legal Citation which is located in the reference section of the library.
Formatting
The object of formatting any paper or assignment is to make it easy to read and locate information of interest. A case brief is no different. Be sure to use headings to mark the beginning of each section of the brief and to organize it in a way that is both visually aesthetic and easy for someone to read. Below is an example of how this might be accomplished based on a case with two issues and one judicial opinion. Remember, you will need to adjust the formatting to accommodate more (or less issues) or where there is an appellate decision containing more than one judicial opinion. Be sure to staple your assignment together and include a cover page with your name, student number, and the title of the assignment.
Case Citation
Facts:
The plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle collision with the defendant…blah, blah, blah….
Procedural History:
The plaintiff sued the defendant in B.C. Provincial Court for negligence blah, blah, blah, blah…
Issues:
Issue #1: Was the defendant negligent when he drove with his eyes closed and collided with the plaintiff’s car?
Issue #2: State the second issue (if there is one)
Decisions:
Issue#1: Yes, the defendant was negligent when he drove with his eyes closed and collided with the plaintiff’s car.
Issue#2: Decision for the 2nd issue (if there is one).
Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social…
Clearly stating the definition, the values, the meaning of such values and the type of…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…
https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/04/25/605092520/high-paying-trade-jobs-sit-empty-while-high-school-grads-line-up-for-university Click on the link above. Read the entire link and answer the questions below…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…