As the assignment states, you were expected to respond to, both, the play by Hwang and the short story by Long. Your essay only refers to the play and, at that, it is not until the end of the second page that you stop summarizing information and start analyzing the play. However, as your conclusion reveals, you spend more time “agreeing with Garber” rather than offering your own argument. In several places, you make sweeping and misrepresentative claims. For instance, when you note “that in the 1980s, homosexuality was not accepted in the West,” consider that this seems to imply that homosexuality was accepted in the “East.” You may have not intended to give this impression, but it is created by the way you have structured this point. In another part of the essay, you refer to Garber to argue that the press “did not make a similar judgment on the male partner, Boursicot” regarding his homosexuality. This is not what Garber is suggesting. Rather, she aligns Boursicot’s sexuality with his nationality, implying that, for the French, the notion that a Frenchman could not tell the difference between a man and a woman was more embarrassing than has it been evident that Boursicot was a homosexual. At several points in your essay, I am quite confused by what you mean. Take this statement: “the man in a relationship who takes the role of a woman.” What does this mean? As I stated repeatedly in my lectures, Song is gender-fluid. While Song is playing a role in the relationship with Boursicot, what if you thought of that role as being less about gender and more about Song being a spy, which is in fact exactly what Song is! For your final assignment, please pay careful attention to the assignment!! Read it and make sure that you understand its requirements. Moreover, always begin with your argument. I do NOT need a summary; I need to know what YOU think.
NAME
COURSE
PROFESSOR
DATE
Reflection paper of M. BUTTERFLY
According to Garber, 121-123, the play brings out two conflicting stereotypes from the West and East, as portrayed by the way different nations received the news of the relationship between the French and the Chinese opera singer who turned out to be a spy. The British media did not criticize the homosexual part of the play but emphasized on the spy part blaming the diplomat of falling for the well know the trick, while other nations like French openly condemned the secret act of man and man relationship. The actions by the French show that the act of homosexuality was not accepted in the 1980s, and those nations were ready to overlook the impact of being spied and base their judgment on the action of same-sex relationships. According to Hwang 86-87, this was just another West-East romance that was misunderstood by the Western stereotype and racist cliché that existed during the 1980s. According to Garber 121-124, the same story was also not received well by the Americans whose media went ahead to interview to ascertain the truth. However, they ended up propagating the same hate and critic towards the gay “woman” who turned out to be gay and did not make a similar judgment on the male partner, Boursicot. For them, Shi (the male partner who pretended to be a woman) conducted himself with secrecy and was not ashamed to have a relationship with a diplomat. While the diplomat may have realized that he was having a relationship with a man, he was not blamed since they concluded that he might have feared to say it. These double standards by the West nations can be said to have to unfairness towards the same-sex partners and even worse to the man in a relationship who takes the role of a woman.
Hwang clearly states that the two reasons; stereotype and racist cliché are the ones that pushed him to come up with a play and not a song, so as he could break the two and showcase that the Chinese culture or notion of women being submissive and bowing to their partners was not authentic (Hwang 86-92). He hoped that after showcasing the play, the misunderstanding and unfairness that was being directed towards the same-sex partners could be accepted, but he was surprised at how many critics the play received after that (Hwang 87). The negative review implied that the homosexual subject was unwelcomed in the 1980s and even though the community had such couples, most of them were either ashamed to say it or feared to spoil their reputation in the community, as depicted in the play where Shi preferred to stay in his friends’ apartments whom he refers as protectors and living his life as a fading diva (Garber 122). This shows that the community treated the “woman” in the relationship as an outcast while the other partner was judged softly since they viewed him as the man, and he was created to be a man in any relationship, whether homosexual or not.
Analyzing the response of the Western press and readers, this paper separates issues into three categories, namely the West superiority stereotype, the racist cliché, and unacceptable relationship that may have started by the already judged Shi the man from the East. The three categories are elaborated broadly as per the two materials on M. Butterfly by Garber and Hwang.
The first category of West superiority is brought out by the way three western nations reviewed the story of Shi the Asian “woman” and Boursicot, the French “man” diplomat. Even though the deserved equal condemnation from the media and community, it is clear that the woman is the one who is harshly condemned and also has to hide from the public (Garber 125-128; Hwang 87-88). Most authors and reviewers of M. Butterfly play, agree with this paper that, the case could have been different were it to be two men from the West who were involved in the act, and the issue of spying could not have been said to be true. The same is captured by Garber 128-135 and Hwang 88-90, who agrees that the play could have had different reviews if they could have used women and men actors from the West.
The other category of racist cliché is that of use of same names like Oriental as per Hwang 85, sounded racist as opposed to the use of the name Asian. The racist idea was also employed by the play, whereby the change of events from French to China to depict change from male to female, Garber 130, that leave one to want to know the implication of that scene if it had been acted vice versa. Also, according to Garber 122-124, the west press and readers felt that the Asian man was to blame, making them want to interview him as opposed to the French diplomat.
The last category of the unacceptable relationship as captured by Garber 135-142; Hwang 89-92, shows that in the 1980s, homosexuality was not accepted in the West and as symbolized by darkness and living in protectors’ apartments, it shows the act was shameful, and people found were not accepted by the majority in the community. It can also be agreed that most of the review and critic that the play received were due to the same-sex actors and nudity captured in the play (Hwang 92). This category also made the directors of this play ashamed of their role in the production of the play, as Hwang 92 states that the director did not push for the commercialization of the play. A closer analysis of the story and play makes one wonder if the theme of the play would have changed from homosexual partners to that of a man and woman, whether the spying narrative would have been captured as it did by the various nations.
This paper concludes by agreeing with Garber 139-145, that plays that have women and men actors have good reviews and great pleasure to the audience. Because most actors used in the play M. Butterfly had their origin from the East; China and Japan, where homosexuality was unacceptable in the 1980s. Also, the Western superiority that is depicted in the play can be likened to the exploitation and submissiveness of the East to the West, where the audience and reviewers fail to accept that homosexuality existed even in the 1980s and judging of the woman in the relationship continues to deny people their rights.
Work Cited
Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social…
Clearly stating the definition, the values, the meaning of such values and the type of…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…
https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/04/25/605092520/high-paying-trade-jobs-sit-empty-while-high-school-grads-line-up-for-university Click on the link above. Read the entire link and answer the questions below…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…