Question 1: Write a moral argument in favor of either Action A or Action B. Label your premises and conclusion. Label which statements are moral and which are non-moral.
Moral argument for action A:
Question 2: Think like a utilitarian. Describe the consequences of Action A, along with the pleasures and pains associated with these consequences. Make sure to include how everyone involved is affected. Then, do the same for Action B.
| Consequences | Pleasures | Pains | |
| Action A | · You maintain your friendships with your best friend and their partner · Your best friend and their partner stay together and stay in love · You and your best friend feel guilty | · You and your 2 friend’s joy and support from each other’s friendships · Your best friend’s and their partner’s joy and support from their romantic relationship
| · You and your best friend live with guilty feelings about not telling your best friend’s partner |
| Action B | · Your best friend’s partner finds out that she has been cheated on · You lose your friendship with your best friend | · Both you and your friend are released from your guilt of not telling his partner about the cheating · Your best friend learns that cheating on a significant other is hurtful and impacts others negatively and may threaten his relationships | · You miss and lose out on a future relationship with your best friend · Your best friend and their partner either have a strained or ruined relationship · Your best friend’s partner experiences emotional hurt because of the cheating · Your best friend experiences emotional hurt at you breaking your promise and ending the friendship and misses out on the future friendship |
Question 3: Again, put your utilitarian thinking cap on. Should you perform Action A or Action B? Explain your answer using the Principle of Utility (aka the Greatest Happiness Principle) and by applying at least 2 of the factors/elements of calculating happiness.
Certainty – you know for certain that your best friend feels very guilty about the cheating and that your best friend will break off the friendship with you if you tell his secret so both these pains are very certain; the other pleasures and pains are uncertain (i.e. your best friend’s partner may not feel hurt, they may just move on and not think much of it)
Extent – more people experience pain in Action B than in Action A (in action A there is no pain for your best friend’s partner, but in action B all 3 of you experience pain)
Looking at the pleasures and pains associated with Action A and Action B, both these factors determine Action A to be the most utilitarian because it has less pain associated with it than Action B
Question 4: Now, think like a Kantian. For Action A, What is the maxim (general rule) implied by this action? Briefly describe what would happen if we universalized this maxim. Do any contradictions or self-defeating states of affairs arise from universalizing the maxim? If so, describe them. Then, do the same for Action B.
Action A:
Maxim – If you make a promise, you have to keep it.
Universalized – Everyone everywhere would keep all the promises they made
Contradictions – None
Action B:
Maxim – You do not have to keep promises you make
Universalized – Everyone everywhere does not have to keep any promises that they make
Contradictions – Maxim defeats itself, because it results in a contradiction, if this maxim is universalized, then promises don’t mean anything, so false promises don’t exist, it is a logical contradiction, so we know that this action is wrong, it results in a perfect duty with no exceptions
Question 5: Using your Kantian thinking cap, does either possible course of action involve treating someone merely as a means (in other words, would performing the action in question mean that you are using someone)? Explain. From the Kantian perspective, is the possible course of action described above right or wrong? If it is wrong, which part of Kant’s “test” did it fail?
Action A: You could be using your friend’s significant other by withholding information about your best friend’s cheating on her in order to keep your friendship with your best friend. You are disrespecting the rationality and dignity of your friend’s significant other because you are joining your friend in pretending that nothing is wrong in your best friend and his partner’s relationship, especially because their partner is your friend as well and you will be going along in your friendship pretending like the cheating never happened.
From a Kantian perspective, this would be a wrong action because it violates the second test “Act so that you use humanity always as an end in itself, never merely as a means.”
Question 6: [This question is not graded, but helps when you need to provide feedback on each other’s assignments. It is also used to help the instructor adjust the course for future sections.] Which part of this Unit’s reading was the most difficult? Is there any part of the material you find confusing? Do you have any questions?
I found the Kantian material to be the most difficult because it was more complicated that the other material and it seems a little subjective depending on how you look at a situation
As part of your grade, you will be required to anonymously provide feedback on another student’s assignment for each unit. Explaining material to someone else requires you to think about the material in a different way, and will ultimately help you understand it better. Receiving feedback and a different perspective from your peers can also help you reach a new understanding.
Provide comments on their work using the comment box or by leaving annotated comments. This includes attempting to answer any questions and respond to any comments the student has about the material. You should also try to highlight any common mistakes and help him/her if they appear to be struggling with the material. This may include trying to explain the material or give tips about how you work through the problems yourself. Your comments should be specific and constructive. Only leaving comments like “Nice job!” or “This is wrong” are not enough to get you credit for the peer review. Explain why they did a nice job or why they are wrong.
If you are unfamiliar with how to use the peer review function on Canvas, please watch the following video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkgPvezGpX8&feature=emb_logo
Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social…
Clearly stating the definition, the values, the meaning of such values and the type of…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…
https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/04/25/605092520/high-paying-trade-jobs-sit-empty-while-high-school-grads-line-up-for-university Click on the link above. Read the entire link and answer the questions below…
All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…