Categories: Uncategorized

Examining the Impact of Perceived Emotional Intelligence Leadership Styles upon the Employee Engagement among Public Sector Employees Assignment | Custom Assignment Help

This assignment should be completed using PowerPoint. The attached proposal must be reviewed and used to complete the Powerpoint assignment. I have also attached an example of a finished PowerPoint assignment that is a guide and must be followed.

 

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Examining the Impact of Perceived Emotional Intelligence Leadership Styles upon the Employee Engagement among Public Sector Employees Assignment | Custom Assignment Help
Get an essay WRITTEN FOR YOU, Plagiarism free, and by an EXPERT!
Order Essay

Examining the Impact of Perceived Emotional Intelligence Leadership Styles upon the Employee Engagement among Public Sector Employees

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

July 5, 2020

 

 

Introduction

 

Employee engagement was first defined by Kahn (1990) as people who employ and express themselves physically, cognitively, and emotionally during role performances in their workplace. Engagement is the “simultaneous employment and expression of a person’s ‘preferred self’ in task behaviors that promote connections to work and to others, personal presence (physical, cognitive, and emotional), and active, full role performance” (Kahn, 1990, p. 700). Personal disengagement refers to “the uncoupling of selves from work roles; in disengagement, people withdraw and defend themselves physically, cognitively, or emotionally during role performances” (Kahn, 1990, p. 692). When an employee begins a new position, most are passionate and excited to begin a new chapter in their professional careers and contribute towards the success of the organization. They want to do an excellent job and make a valuable contribution to the company. What happens to the passion of the employees after the first year in their job position? Why does the fire go out in the engaged employee?

Employee disengagement occurs from both intrapersonal and external factors that include obscurity of organizational vision, inefficient team-building framework, negative social relations, non-inclusivity in the communication of organizational progress, the rigidity of working conditions, non-impact feeling of the workforce, and poor incentive-reward framework (Sharma, Chaudhary, & Singh, 2019).   In 2015, Gallup concluded after interviewing more than 80,000 adults who were employed full time or part-time for an employer found that 51% of employees were not engaged in their job positions and 17% were disengaged (Adkins, 2016). Workers were categorized as being engaged based on how they rate key workplace elements. These elements are someone at work encouraging their development and believing that their opinion matters, and having the chance to do what they do best every day (Adkins, 2016). As a result, the engaged employees become committed to their work. According to Cunningham (2019), disengaged employees can be hostile, only do the minimum required work, are more likely to miss work and change jobs whenever an opportunity arises.

Disengaged employees are those who have quit, but do not necessarily submit a resignation to retain their source of income. Their withdrawal manifests through missed deadlines, poor attendance, and being problem-focused rather than solution-based (Imperatori, 2017).  The negativity from disengaged employees can spread throughout the organizational culture causing susceptible to negative utterances about the company, the leaders and other team members (Rheem, 2018).

Statement of Problem

Emotional Intelligence is a term created by two researchers – Peter Salovey and John Mayer – and popularized by Daniel Goleman in his 1997 book titled: “Emotional Intelligence”. It is defined as the ability to recognize, understand and manage our own emotions and recognize, understand and influence the emotions of others (Goleman, 2004). In practical terms, this means being aware that emotions can drive our behavior and impact people (positively and negatively) and learning how to manage those emotions – both our own and others – especially when we are under pressure. Goleman (2004) concluded that effective leaders, managers and co-workers, must be able to read the social environment of an organization.  He discovered that leaders who care about how they make employees feel set the tone of the workplace and can control how much an employee gives to the company.

Goleman’s (2004) research led him to conclude there are five components in Emotional Intelligence or EI that include: self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy and social skills. Self-aware managers recognize how their feelings impact employees. They are not overly critical, but honest with themselves and others.  Self-regulation helps managers control their negative emotions instead of being controlled by them. Additionally, it helps to manage the negative impulses felt by all managers (Goleman, 2004).

The third component of emotional intelligence is motivation.  When leaders are self-motivated they motivate their employees to work on their goals and hold high-quality standards for their work.  Additionally, self-motivated leaders have an emotional connection to employees that is healthy. Thus, they can achieve the results they want without being obsessive (Goleman, 2004). Empathy is the fourth component and is defined as knowing how to treat others who have different personality traits. This component is about having the social skills to build connections that help get the work done when the company isn’t doing well.  These five components of EI include six leadership approaches that could be used interchangeably: visionary, coaching, affiliative, democratic, pace setting and commanding leadership (Goleman, 2004).

There are substantial publications relating to the effectiveness of roles of emotional intelligence leadership and employee involvement in the private sector.  The public sector counterparts have limited, if any, comprehensive research publications about the existence of a significant correlation among emotional intelligent leaders, workforce, and employee engagement index.  Imperatively, in this research, the use of a hundred-  based questionnaire under conditions of workforce anonymity will help in uplifting managerial outcomes as a worthwhile consideration recalling that the niche suffers a long duration of neglect.

Prior Research

Suehs (2015) recorded the study about emotional intelligence and employee engagement and agreed there needs to be more evidence by assessing supervisors and managers in a private sector hospital.  The research questions focused on: (a) what is the level of employee engagement among the study participants, (b) what is the level of emotional intelligence of the frontline managers and supervisors who participated in the study, and (c) using inferential statistics, is there a statistically significant correlation between emotional intelligence of frontline managers and supervisors and the employee engagement of their direct reports (Suehs, 2015). The quantitative study used the results of 24 front-line managers and supervisors and employee engagement of their 585 employees to deny or prove the hypothesis. This study found that there is a link between emotional intelligence among managers and supervisors, and the level of how emotionally and actively engaged they were in daily and strategic activities of the organization. The study concluded that emotionally intelligent leaders create a workplace where their employees are valued, empowered and engaged. From the study, the leaders in the private sector must have emotional intelligence, as having emotionally intelligent leaders in the workplace increases the number of employees who are actively engaged (Suehs, 2015). The study was conducted in a private sector hospital; however, it poses the question that if emotionally intelligent leaders are important in the private sector are emotionally intelligent leadership styles important in the public sector?

A study conducted by Soyars and Brusino (2009) researched the “Essentials of Engagement” at Morrison which is from an organization that offers nutrition, food, and dining services. They define employee engagement as workers who are emotionally and mentally committed in their jobs and are promoting the success of their employer. These workers know what they are doing in the work environment to advance the company’s success. However, a study by the American Society for Training and Development revealed that about one-third of workers are actively engaged in their jobs (Soyars & Brusino, 2009). Moreover, the study associated employee engagement with three aspects: growth and development, connections and contributions. In this case, contributions require the company to communicate its vision and mission to its employees. In this sense, employees will have a sense of pride in what the organization is striving to achieve. Soyars and Brusino (2009) asserted that positive associations between a manager and an employee have a positive correlation between employee engagement and performance. Additionally, they attributed growth and development as essential tools of employee engagement.

Soyars and Brusino (2009) showed a practical example of how essential engagement is at Morrison where there was a reduction in employee turnover with the initiation of additional learning opportunities and a yearly involvement survey. Morrison created meaningful contributions with workers through its mission and vision including its web address. The organization also established connections through the CHAT (Communication, Help and Training) program, which involved monthly meetings of employees. Furthermore, the company offered opportunities for learning through a development plan for each employee and included learning opportunities via stretch assignments. Through these activities, there was a 15% reduction in employee turnover by the company. The case study revealed several methods of enhancing worker involvement through better development and management processes. The company also used a small number of resources to make employee engagement a reality, which resulted in finding that when organizations hold all managers or all employees responsible for employee engagement – a more pervasive culture is implemented that leads to higher employee involvement (Soyars and Brusino, 2009).

Conceptual Model

Publications on emotional intelligence allude to a crucial ingredient to the workforce in public institutions; however, there is not enough research to support the significance and correlation between emotional intelligence leadership and workforce engagement especially in the public sector.  This study will explore the relationship between employee engagement and perceived emotional intelligence leadership styles in a public sector setting. The quantitative study will determine if there is a connection between these two concepts from the public sector, specifically a utility company.

 

 

 

 

 

Figure 1: Conceptual model inferred from Van Wart, M. (2014), Lowman and Thomas (2015)

and Byrne, Z. S. (2014)

Based on Figure 1 of the conceptual model, the research questions and null hypotheses include:

Research Question 1: Is there a statistically significant correlation between a leader or supervisor approach to emotional intelligence and employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1: There is a statistically significant correlation between a leader or supervisor approach to emotional intelligence and employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0: There is no statistically significant correlation between a leader or supervisor approach to emotional intelligence and employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

Research Question 2: Is there a statistically significant correlation between a visionary emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1: There is a statistically significant correlation between a visionary emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0: There is no statistically significant correlation between a visionary emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.     

Research Question 3:  Is there a statistically significant correlation between a coaching emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1:  There is a statistically significant correlation between a coaching emotional leadership competency relationship and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0:  There is no statistically significant correlation between a coaching emotional leadership competency relationship and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

Research Question 4:  Is there a statistically significant correlation between affiliative emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1: There is a statistically significant correlation between affiliative emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0: There is no statistically significant correlation between affiliative emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

Research Question 5: Is there a statistically significant correlation between pace setting emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1: There is a statistically significant relationship between pace setting emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0: There is no statistically significant relationship between pace setting emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

Research Question 6: Is there a statistically significant correlation between democratic emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1: There is a statistically significant correlation between democratic emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0: There is no statistically significant correlation between democratic emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

Research Question 7: Is there a statistically significant correlation between commanding emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting?

H1: There is a statistically significant relationship between commanding emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

H0: There is no statistically significant relationship between commanding emotional leadership competency and the employee’s workplace engagement in a public sector setting.

 

Summary

            The purpose of this quantitative study is to reveal if there is a correlation between emotionally intelligent leadership styles and employee engagement in the public sector. The study will contribute to the psychology field to assess if employee engagement is increased or decreased when certain leadership styles have emotionally intelligent competencies. In this area, there is limited research in studying the relationship between emotional engagement and emotional intelligence in the public sector. The current quantitative study seeks to close this gap.

 

 

 

 

 

 

CHAPTER 2

Literature Review

Historical Context of Employee Engagement

One of the most influential theories in employee workplace engagement is Herzberg’s motivation and hygiene theory first published in 1971 (Herzberg, 1971). Herzberg (1971) provided the two-factor theory that included motivation and hygiene theories. Herzberg (1971) developed the theory after interviewing more than 200 accountants and engineers, which showed that job satisfaction was dependent on two separate continuums.

The two-factor theory contains four states. The first state is high hygiene and high motivation. In this state, employees have fewer grievances and are motivated.  The second state is high hygiene and low motivation.  In this circumstance, employees may have few grievances but are not highly motivated. The third state occurs when there are low hygiene and high motivation. Under this state, the employees are highly motivated, but have a lot of grievances.  Finally, low hygiene and low motivation states are the most challenging for an organization, as employees are not motivated and do not have the right hygiene factors (Herzberg, 1971).

According to Herzberg (1971), six hygiene factors promote employee satisfaction: recognition, achievement, interesting work, responsibility, growth and advancement. Motivators encourage employees to work harder while the hygiene factors do not encourage employees to work harder because they become unmotivated when they are not present.  First, recognition is when the manager gives an employee praise on the success they have achieved. In achievement, the job should give the employee a sense of achievement. Interesting work is described as the job being interesting as well as a challenge for employees to foster engagement. Responsibility is when employees hold themselves accountable for their work. Additionally, employees look for opportunities to grow by learning new skills through formal training or on the job training.  Finally, organizations should offer promotion opportunities to create opportunities for advancement. Instead of these hygiene factors, there should also be amicable relationships between subordinates, superiors, and peers; working conditions need to be safe and hygienic; salaries should be fair and reasonable, and employees need to have security in the workplace versus worry about being laid off. This key theory can be used to improve team performance (Herzberg, 1971).

There are two ways how the two-factor model can be used to increase motivation in the workplace that includes eliminating job hygiene stressors and boosting job satisfaction. The first thing leaders should do to enhance the motivation of their team is to make sure that hygiene factors do not cause any dissatisfaction. Some of the steps to eliminate job stressors include rectifying the bureaucratic company policies, ensuring there is supportive work culture, ensuring the team members are supported, and ensuring that there is a competitive salary.  The other way is for leaders to boost job satisfaction. There are three techniques managers can use to boost job satisfaction that includes job enrichment, job enlargement and employee empowerment. Job enrichment refers to enriching the employee’s job by giving them complex tasks. Job enlargement is when the employees are given a variety of tasks to complete. Employee empowerment entails giving workers a particular degree of responsibility and autonomy for decision-making concerning specific company roles (Herzberg, 1971).

Herzberg’s motivation theory has limitations that include only doing research on white-collar workers and only focuses on improving employee satisfaction. Further, this theory does not take into consideration the individual’s perception; therefore there is no way to measure employee satisfaction.  The main concern with this theory is that it focuses on the “average” behavior of employees. The reality is that there are significant differences that may determine the behavior of individuals. For instance, employees who pursue long term objectives may deviate from the “average” behavioral pattern (Herzberg, 1971). Despite the challenges and limitations, the benefit of this theory is the consideration of both “visible” and “invisible” factors of motivation.

Leadership impact on Employee Engagement

For organizations in the public sector to survive, they depend on profit maximization from existing capabilities. Furthermore, they should adjust and recognize what may not work and what will work in the future (Osborne & Hammoud, 2017). The study by Osborne and Hammoud (2017), on “Effective Employee Engagement in the Workplace” used self-determination theory as a conceptual framework and also defined employee engagement as the level to which workers feel zealous concerning their work, put discretional effort into their jobs and are committed to the company. This theory examined the different impacts of employee involvement on organizations. Osborne and Hammoud (2017) used 440 direct reviews who offer emotional intelligence ratings of approximately 222 leaders. There was the utilization of direct reports and leadership in three large organizations – two from the IT industry and one from the entertainment industry. The study used a 12 – item survey method to collect data on leadership styles.

The authors used face-to-face interviews to collect data. There was a variation in the follow-up questions depending on the experience of participants. The aim of the follow-up questions was for the respondents to expound on their experiences. For confidentiality, the authors gave every respondent a numeric identifier. Additionally, there was a review of organizational policies and personal files concerning strategies of worker involvement to confirm and triangulate interview information.

The study consisted of a six-step analysis; the first included reading through all the information; the second was the organization and preparation of data analysis. The third step was the beginning of a detailed report via a coding process.  The fourth approach identified themes and descriptions in a qualitative narrative. The fifth included using the coding process in generating a report and finally developing meaning to the data. The sixth step was the development of meaning or interpretation of data. In this case, Osborne and Hammoud (2017) found that empowering employees is an essential factor. Employees need leaders who provide challenges in their work and empowerment. Additionally, employees need leaders who trust them in completing tasks. Furthermore, Osborne and Hammoud (2017) found that rewards and recognition improved employee involvement through motivation. Empowering employees requires the organization to offer quality training and provide resources for employees to complete their tasks. This will improve the confidence of employees, thereby enhancing their work output (Osborne and Hammoud, 2017).

The study recommended that focusing on recognition and rewards serve as an advantage in improving communication within organizations. Furthermore, the study suggested the utilization of management abilities to leverage worker involvement in a company. It concluded that these factors are necessary for active worker engagement in the workplace (Osborne and Hammoud, 2017).

The article “Investigating Leadership Styles and Employee Engagement in Small-to-Medium Defense Contractor Organizations” by Wright (2019), established a relationship between worker involvement and leadership styles in the context of small to medium defense organizations. The research mainly acknowledged transformational leadership as a form of leadership that effectively incorporated worker involvement. It also studied other leadership styles such as passive-avoidance and transactional. Furthermore, it gave the advantages of different leadership styles concerning employee engagement.

The quantitative correlational study used observations, surveys and questionnaires for data collection. The target population included only employees who rated their employer’s leadership styles. In this case, workers could give more accurate answers about the leadership styles of their direct leader and their participation in the work environment. The sample population was 82 participants from Texas and Michigan. The statistical tests used in this case were the Utrecht Work Engagement Scale-9 (UWES-9) and the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire (MLQ) 5X Short (Wright, 2019). The total mean scores (M = 4.71, SD = .85) from the UWES-9 survey results revealed the participants felt engaged very often at least a few times a week based on the rating scale (Wright, 2019). The total mean scores from the MLQ-5X Short survey results revealed the participants perceived transformational leadership as the most prevalent leadership style their leaders exhibited in the organization (Wright, 2019). Out of the three leadership styles, transformational leadership had the highest rating (M = 2.70, SD = .75) (Wright, 2019).  The total mean scores (M = 4.71, SD = .85) from the UWES-9 survey results revealed the participants felt engaged very often at least a few times a week based on the rating scale (Wright, 2019).

The study affirmed that transformational leadership related positively to employee engagement, transactional leadership; however, it had little influence on the participation of employees. The passive avoidance leadership styles had little effect on the engagement of employees. In this case, there was no significant relationship between the manager and the employee. In most cases, the employee does most of the organizational work on their own. For employee involvement, there have to be aspects of inspirational skills that are available in the transformational leadership style (Wright, 2019).

Wright (2019), recommended that managers become more transformational to achieve maximum employee involvement. The article concluded that leadership styles matter when it comes to employee involvement. Additionally, transformational leadership is the most effective leadership style when an organization wants to achieve maximum employee involvement.

Xu and Thomas (2011), in their study “How can Leaders Achieve High Employee Engagement?” described transformational leaders as people who challenge and inspire employees to surpass their interests and establish objectives for the organization as a whole. They also described the meaning of employee engagement concerning organizational leadership. This article examined the antecedents of worker engagement. The authors mentioned these antecedents as employee willingness to make use of their skills, be more productive and have better well-being. Xu and Thomas (2011) also examined connections between follower engagement and leader behavior to find ways to achieve employee engagement. The other constructs included the position of leadership and tenure and their relationship with commitment.

The qualitative study used respondents from an insurance company in New Zealand. The methodology involved an invitation of 260 direct reports to rate their immediate supervisors. In this case study, there was a rating of 41 managers utilizing the 360-degree feedback measure. Among the 260 direct reports, the response was received from 235, yielding a response of approximately 90.3%. T. After a three-month study duration, workers from the most extensive section of the organization were to respond to the 360-degree feedback measure.

Results from the 360 – degree feedback measure indicated three emerging factors: displays integrity, performs effectively and supports the team. Semi partial correlations indicated that the display of integrity, effective performance and supporting the team had an overlapping relationship. Regression and correlation showed that the strongest predictor of involvement was leaders who supported the team. Based on the findings of this study, transformational leadership has a crucial function in engagement. The research showed that four constituents of transformational leadership exist.  The first is idealized influence, which involves followers identifying and trusting their leader. The second is inspirational motivation, which includes leaders providing challenges and meaningful work for the followers. Intellectual stimulation is the third component. It involves managers rejuvenating followers’ proactivity and adaptability in a blame-free context. Finally, individualized consideration is the fifth element. It is the process by which managers support the specific requirements of followers for growth and achievement. The research concluded that leaders who supported and developed team members, worked effectively, and displayed integrity have more employees who are engaged.  The strengths of the study included using a thorough behavioral measure of leadership and a theoretically based instrument for employee engagement. The study found that future research should be done to establish how leaders can keep their employees engaged and use resources toward enhancing employee engagement (Xu & Thomas, 2011).

A quantitative study by Soyars & Brusino (2009) defined employee engagement as three elements: contributions, connections, and growth and advancement. They also defined employee engagement as employees who are committed to their work and want to contribute to the success of the organization. The researchers used a non-participant observation research method.  The observation was continuous for a period of two months with participants from the finance and procurement department, each having leaders. The research used descriptive statistical analysis to summarize meaningful data on employee engagement. In this case, there was the use of Chi-Square to test for the correlation between contributions, connections, growth and advancement, and employee commitment. This study found that only one-third of the employees are fully engaged in their different workplaces (Soyars & Brusino, 2009). Ninety percent of companies surveyed agreed that employee engagement is important and the mission should be communicated to the employees. However, only 52% of companies state they are focused on employee engagement as a high priority (Soyars & Brusino, 2009). The first element of employee engagement is contribution and depends on the communication of the company’s mission which will enable employees to contribute to its success (Soyars & Brusino, 2009). The second element of employee engagement is connections, and this is defined as healthy friendships. The third element involved growth and advancement, meaning employees are allowed to participate in training programs offered by the organization (Soyars & Brusino, 2009).

In the article “Breaking Engagement Apart: The Role of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation in Engagement Strategies”, Delaney and Royal (2017) aimed at scrutinizing worker motivation as a critical factor of commitment. They also examined the outcomes and antecedents of motivation, including their dynamics and methods in which companies can harness and foster motivation. The article identified motivation as a critical element of performance and employee commitment. It determined building capability, change management, and knowledge management as key drivers of engagement. The authors concluded that the primary predictor of employee commitment is self-motivation and external motivation.

Delaney and Royal (2017) identified two different motivation forms: one that is self-derived (intrinsic) and one that is externally derived (extrinsic). There was the utilization of observation and surveys as data collection methods. After this, the researchers used ANOVA to test the difference between extrinsic and intrinsic means after accounting for variance in the outcome variables. According to the global employee opinion normative benchmarks, the study found that 76% of employees who exceeded performance expectations felt motivated to do more than what was required of them, compared with 67% of employees who meet performance expectations and 57% of employees who do not, which suggests that intrinsic motivation is associated with better performance. Korn Ferry Hay Group’s global normative benchmarks were based on data collected from over 6.4 million employees in 390 organizations around the world in a variety of industries (Delaney & Royal, 2017). Achieving intrinsic motivation required the task goal to align itself with the personal objectives of an individual. On the other hand, extrinsic motivation is one that the organization or the environment initiated through activities as rewards. In two separate experiments, the research found a 76% improvement in performance when employees felt motivated (intrinsic). Contrarily, there was a 67% performance improvement when motivation comes from the company (Delaney & Royal, 2017). Extrinsic motivation is external to the individual and is connected to the work environment and organization (Delaney & Royal, 2017).  Extrinsic motivation is defined as leaders having a role to play in ensuring that all the employees are well engaged based on the particular leadership approach taken.  The research concluded that organizations should work to close the motivation gap to ensure that employees perform at a high level (Delaney & Royal, 2017).

Leader Emotional Intelligence and Employee Engagement

Quang, Khuong, and Le (2015) conducted a study to investigate how leaders apply emotional intelligence to formulate the leadership styles and improve employee job engagement.   The study was carried out on 400 white-collar employees working in Hoa Binh Corporation and its subsidiaries in Ho Chi Minh City. Quang, Khuong, and Le (2015) look into emotional intelligence, employee engagement, change resilience, self-motivation, self-esteem and emotional literacy as factors that influence worker involvement.

The paper utilizes numerical data to investigate the competencies of emotional intelligence on worker engagement. Out of a total of 2,000 workers, there was a selection of 400 employees within the Hoa Binh Corporation. The method of data collection was mixed methods using questionnaires and interviews.  Additionally, the study utilizes observation as a method of collecting data. In data analysis, the study utilizes exploratory factor analysis, which involved Varimax rotation and Principle component analysis to discover their convergence and structure in the model. According to the data analysis, interpersonal relationships and self-esteem correlate positively with worker engagement (Quang, Khuong, & Le, 2015). They all fall under the emotional intelligence competency category. Additionally, emotional literacy and self-management had a moderate relationship with worker involvement. Change resilience and self- motivation had a low association with improving the engagement of workers. (Quang, Khuong, and Le (2015) found that self-motivation and emotional literacy influenced employee involvement. The study indicated that a leader’s emotional intelligence competencies such as self-esteem, self-motivation, interpersonal relations and emotional literacy had a positive effect on employee engagement. Moreover, the leader’s competency regarding change resilience negatively affected employee engagement. Managers should conduct a self-assessment to find out what they feel, the root of the feeling, and what the feeling means. Leaders should always communicate with their followers to have a deeper understanding of their moods and what they feel internal (Quang et al., 2015). From the results of the study, the research found that emotionally intelligent leaders should develop workforce engagement (Quang et al., 2015).

In the article “Antecedents of organizational engagement: Exploring vision, mood ad perceived organizational support with emotional intelligence as a moderator,” Mahon, Taylor and Boyatzis (2014) set out to fill a gap of the engagement antecedents. They review available research on antecedent involvement and define worker involvement. Mahon, Taylor and Boyatzis (2014) tested the relationship between organizational support and worker involvement. They tried to establish whether personal characteristics influence the relationship between the two concepts.

The collection of data was from one not-for-profit school and one for-profit public company. There was an exchange of approximately 638 involvement surveys between these two consenting organizations with a response rate of 45%. Two hundred thirty-one complete surveys were available for analysis after linking perceived organizational support to an increase in performance within the organization. The researchers had hypothesized that perceived organizational support, shared positive mood, shared personal vision, and emotional intelligence has a positive association with organizational engagement (Mahon et al., 2014).  The study uses a Chi-square test to ensure the validity of measures. The results of the study found that emotional intelligence moderates the shared personal vision with organizational engagement, but it is not always done positively. The article contributes to the growing comprehension of emotional intelligence by displaying its magnifying impact on perceived organizational support and shared goals concerning participation. The authors recommend further studies in this area to further widen the understanding of the antecedents of employee engagement (Mahon et al., 2014). The reason for this is increasing employee disengagement, and pursuing this area of research would give an improved picture of how to handle the issue (Mahon et al., 2014).

Public Sector Employees and Workplace Motivation/Employee Engagement

            Employee motivation can be a difficult concept to evaluate. Achieving workplace motivation can be a challenging task for employers and workers.  Rashid and Rashid’s (2012) study on “Work Motivation Differences between Public and Private Sector” aimed to identify and discuss the elements that affect workers’ motivation.  It sought to identify the differences in the motivational constructs in the private and public industries. Rashid and Rashid (2012) acknowledge that there exist variations in motivation in these sectors. They also affirm that these motivational factors can positively or negatively influence the engagement of employees. In this study, they point out that workers in the privately-owned companies value the financial aspect of employment compared to workers in the public industry. The study was mixed methods that used descriptive research; hence, secondary data and survey methods were utilized to gather the requisite information. The goal of the survey was to establish what elements are impacting employee motivation in private and public banks and whether these elements are distinct in terms of the employment industry. In line with this, there was a calculation of a self-administered questionnaire among the participants. There was the utilization of descriptive statistics to provide critical population variables within this research. Rashid and Rashid (2012) found that the average mean score of financial rewards for employees in the public sector was significantly low compared to those in the private sector. There was the utilization of the t-test in testing the differences between variables in the same population. The study also found that there were no significant differences between the two sectors when it came to intrinsic motivation. Finally, the results of the research also showed that career development had a less motivational impact on public servants.

In their quest to establish the differences in the motivational aspects between private and public industries, Rashid and Rashid (2012) came up with a survey method to collect data from one – hundred fifty workers. These workers were from the private and public banking industries.  The study recruited one-hundred-fifty public and private sector banking personnel.  There were eighty participants from the public sector and seventy from the private sector (Rashid & Rashid, 2012). The public sector banks are those owned by the government while the private sector banks are owned by individuals and corporations.  The goal of the study was to evaluate if work motivation differs from public and private sector banks (Rashid & Rashid, 2012). The research concluded that monetary rewards have more of an influence in the private sector than in the public sector.

In the article, “Public Service and Motivation: Does Mission Matter?” Wright (2007) seeks to find out if the motivation is vital within the organizational settings. The quantitative research advances an individual’s comprehension of workers’ performance and motivation in the public sector. For the study to achieve its goal, it carries out this task within the psychological structure of goal theory. Wright (2007) found out the goal theory offered a theoretical base for comprehending the distinct contributions of public service, task, and mission to workers’ performance and motivation. The quantitative study utilized external consultants to administer the survey for participants that were recruited from a New York agency that consisted of 2,200 workers and approximately 1,900 completed and returned the questionnaires. The study utilizes a univariate analysis to summarize and find patterns in the data. It also uses multivariate analysis to take multiple measurements of every unit of the experiment to find out how each unit relates to the findings.

The study found that motivation is influential when it comes to employee engagement. According to Wright (2007), public organizations go for employees who show commitment to the company’s goal to provide services and goods to the public. He ascertains that there are three essential factors: job-goal importance, performance-goal commitment, and public service and purpose theory motivation. According to Wright (2007), motivation can increase organizational productivity. It has the support construct of employee engagement. Managers who motivate their employees through various forms of motivation not only succeed in engaging their employees but, also enhance the organization’s productivity. The other factor that Wright (2007) mentions is that an organization can operate efficiently through motivation. Well-motivated employees are loyal to the organization and have a high level of commitment and morale. All these factors increase the efficiency of the organization. The study recommended that goal theory is an essential motivation tool in measuring motivation and employee engagement. It concluded that motivation is a critical aspect of an organization and has a positive correlation between performance and the involvement of employees in the public sector.

It was suggested that the goal theory provided a strong theoretical foundation for understanding the separate but related contributions of task and mission. More than 60% of respondents felt they perform challenging tasks exceptionally when the goals are understood and achievable (Wright, 2007). The quantitative study gave both a multivariate analysis and a univariate analysis. The study concluded that public sector employees are more motivated to perform their work when they have clearly understood tasks that they feel are important and achievable. The value that employees see in the mission of their company was found to have an impact on work determination (Wright, 2007).

Brenyah and Obuobisa-Darko (2017) conducted a research study that examined employee engagement among various unspecified public sector employees in the country of Ghana. The quantitative study was completed using two-hundred sixty-seven random participants in the Ghanaian public sector.  Data analysis, in this case, involved the use of both multiple and simple regression. When there is a positive relationship with employee engagement, it means that there is job autonomy in the organization. When employees have more autonomy, they will be more engaged in their work. Additionally, the study also found that there are positive relationships between employee engagement and perceived organizational support (Brenyah & Obuobisa-Darko, 2017).  The organizations with perceived organizational support have mutual trust between employees and the leaders which results in increased employee engagement (Brenyah & Obuobisa-Darko, 2017). The study also showed that there is a positive relationship between achievement culture and employee engagement. Employees in an organization that is achievement-oriented can use their discretion when doing their work. Thus, their level of engagement increases (Brenyah & Obuobisa-Darko, 2017).

Based on the literature review concerning employee engagement and emotional intelligence leadership, it is likely that emotional intelligence among management and workforce in both private and public institutions is a critical ingredient in optimizing efficiency in service delivery and production. Management possesses a critical role in creating and enabling an environment for staff members in public and private institutions to foster optimal involvement through relevant parameters such as monetary incentives, proper communication framework, team building platforms, collective enhancement of impact feeling the flexibility of working conditions, emphasized clarity of organizational goals, among other possible avenues (Sallie-Dosunmu, 2016) (Baker & Waring, 1999).  Previous research findings affirmed the implementation of emotional intelligence leadership styles in private sectors which substantially boosts the performance of staff through workforce motivation index upgrading the given terms of contracts available in the sector. Management possesses a critical role in creating and enabling an environment for staff members in public and private institutions to foster optimal involvement through relevant parameters such as monetary incentives, proper communication framework, team building platforms, collective enhancement of impact feeling the flexibility of working conditions, emphasized clarity of organizational goals, among other possible avenues (Sallie-Dosunmu, 2016, Baker & Waring, 1999). This affirms the existence of a level of significance and correlation between employee engagement and emotional intelligence perception in leadership among private economic infrastructure (Rothwell, 2014).

In conclusion, various studies have shown a correlation between employee engagement and leadership styles. The public sector is lacking comprehensive research studies in this area. The current research study is seeking to fill this gap. This study can help the public sector understand if there is a correlation between employee engagement, leadership styles and emotional intelligence.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CHAPTER 3

 

 

Methodology Section

Participants

The sample population for this research will entail the public utility sector employees aged 24-64 years old located in the Southern region of the United States. Other inclusion criteria include participants who are fluent in English due to the questionnaires, consent forms, and other materials written in English and working either on a full or part-time basis in a public sector setting. The exclusion criteria include participants outside of the designated age group and who do not speak English fluently. . . The participants will be recruited via an online recruitment platform. Using an A-priori Sample Size Calculator for Multiple Regression with at least 6 predictor variables of emotional intelligence dimensions (visionary, coaching, affiliative, democratic, pace setting and commanding emotional leaderships) in predicting the dependent variable of employee engagement. The minimum required sample size is 123 participants to obtain a desired statistical power of 0.90 with a 0.05 statistical significance level (Adkins, 2016).

Measures

A demographic questionnaire will collect information on the participant’s age, gender, work status (part-time versus full-time), yearly income, and the highest level of education. Additional follow-up questions related to the participant’s personal work experience will be asked including their length of time working, previously fired from an employment position and if they have ever been previously promoted. (Adkins, 2016).

All the participants will complete two assessments for this study that include the Utrecht Work Engagement Scale developed by Schaufeli and Bakker (2004) and a modification on the six distinct styles of emotional leadership Likert scale developed by Daniel Goleman (2004). A complete set of questions used in the survey is located in Appendix A.

First, the Utrecht Work Engagement Scale developed by Schaufeli and Bakker (2004) is a 17-item inventory that measures the 3 dimensions the employee engagement (vigor, dedication, and absorption). The UWES previously had 24 items; 9 vigor items and 8 dedication items that had Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) items that were positively rephrased.  The MBI-items were supplemented by the dedication and vigor items and absorption items that constituted the UWES-24 (Brenyah & Obuobisa-Darko, 2017). The reliability of the UWES is done using two aspects: test-retest reliability and internal consistency. Both the internal consistency and test-retest reliability are internally consistent. Thus, adding another item does not increase the internal consistency of the scales.

Finally, the researcher will evaluate the 6 dimensions of emotional intelligence (visionary, coaching, affiliative, democratic, pace setting and commanding emotional leaderships) by Daniel Goleman (2004) focusing on the perception of the public sector employees on their corresponding leaders or supervisors.

Procedure

Participants will be recruited via online methods from social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn for up to four weeks. Participants will be directed to an online survey platform (i.e. Google Survey) to complete the voluntary survey. Surveys will remain anonymous to achieve confidentiality. Participants will be required to read and accept an online consent form to inform them that the survey is voluntary and confidential.  Based on the speed and technicality of the questions, the approximated time for completion is 20-30 minutes.

Proposed Statistical Analyses

This study takes a quantitative approach based on the instruments and questionnaires being used to gather numerical data. The chosen analysis software for this study is IBM-SPSS version 25. Descriptive statistics will be applied in providing summaries of the demographic information of the sampled participants, which will include determining the mean, percentages, and standard deviations and the data collected. Inferential statistics will be applied to examine relationships across the variables. A correlation and linear regression analysis will be used to evaluate the association between the participant’s demographic variables and their performance.

This quantitative research study uses a correlational design on the relationship between leadership styles and emotional intelligence.  Hence, by conducting a correlation, one can make conclusions on the association. Secondly, a regression analysis will help examine the possible statistical relationships between the public sector employee’s perception of the 6 Emotional Intelligence Dimensions (visionary, coaching, affiliative, democratic, pace setting and commanding emotional leadership) towards their leaders or supervisors and the employee’s self-reported employee engagement.

 

In conclusion, all the participants will complete two assessments for this study that include the Utrecht Work Engagement Scale developed by Schaufeli and Bakker (2004) and a modification on the six distinct styles of emotional leadership Likert scale developed by Daniel Goleman (2004). This research study will provide insight into how individuals from the public sector respond to different leadership styles based on emotional intelligence. Currently, the public sector limited, if any, comprehensive research publications about the existence of a significant correlation among emotional intelligent leaders, workforce, and employee engagement index.  Imperatively, in this research, the use of the hundred based questionnaire under conditions of workforce anonymity will help in uplifting managerial outcomes as a worthwhile consideration recalling that the niche suffers a long duration of neglect.

 

 

 

Suzie Mercy

Recent Posts

What is the easy difination of science | Quick Solution

Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social…

4 years ago

definition, values, meaning of such values and type of goods with such elasticity value …….. | Quick Solution

Clearly stating the definition, the values, the meaning of such values and the type of…

4 years ago

Acct 422 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago

Acct 322 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago

Macro Economics Question | Quick Solution

https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/04/25/605092520/high-paying-trade-jobs-sit-empty-while-high-school-grads-line-up-for-university Click on the link above. Read the entire link and answer the questions below…

4 years ago

MGT 322 – Nora D | Quick Solution

All answered must be typed using Times New Roman (size 12, double-spaced) font. No pictures…

4 years ago