Description
Task: Assessment is by one assignment, a critical essay of 6000 words (100%) which integrates theory and practice. The assignment must include a clear structure with an abstract, a list of references and, where appropriate, appendices and diagrams. You must make appropriate use of journal articles and texts. References should follow the Harvard system – see YSJ Harvard at https://www.yorksj.ac.uk/library/refe… The assignment should contain: 1. A critical literature review of key theories of how strategy is developed and implemented, and the relationship between strategy, innovation and change 2. A critical analysis of selected strategic processes within your organisation, or an organisation of your choice, related to relevant theories 3. An assessment of the extent to which people within the organisation are engaged with and contribute to a selected strategy 4. Recommendations about how strategic processes within the organisation could be improved. To preserve confidentiality, please anonymise the organisation or organisations you discuss in the assignment, eg by calling them Company X, or Governmental Organisation Y, or International Organisation Z. Similarly, where you write about private individuals, call them manager A, or leader B. N.B. The word count will include quotations but exclude footnotes, list of references, appendices, tables and graphs. Exhibits will not count against the word limit but should not contain large amounts of text. (It will be expected that they will normally containdiagrams or tables or visual images). Appendices should not contain material that is essential to meeting the assignment brief. If you exceed the wordcount by more than 10%, you will be penalised. This task has a weight of 100% and the deadline to complete is 09 Aug 2020.Michelle Theodore grade report (#259188)
Successful Strategic Thinking – Final paper
Your Assignment
Your paper was satisfactorily presented, with a cover page numbered pages, and would have
been improved with a table of contents. There was an abstract, but at two pages it was
much too long; please remember for future assignments that the abstract is a single
non-indented paragraph (about one third of a page) describing the purpose and contents of
your paper – you should typically present here the motivation, results, and conclusions, and for
this paper, it would be a way of pointing out that you have addressed all the assignment
requirements. The lack of a table of contents was not only an inconvenience, but also
resulted in confusion. Your section headings did not indicate any clear structure to
discriminate between sections and sub-sections, so headings such as Theories (in bold), was
followed by Knowledge-Intensive Theory (not bold), then Price Discrimination Theory (bold),
Problem (bold), and so on.
The list of references was extensive, included some contemporary content, and in general
followed the Harvard referencing system (authors should be listed by family name and initials,
not given names). You need to support statements such as “Reports show that it is more
than 20% of the workforce that works in the service sector” with citations to such reports.
You in-text citations also generally followed Harvard.
You write well, but I found the introduction very confusing. It had no clear theme and jumped
from entrepreneurship to the external environment, the service sector, strategic management,
then back to the service sector. Since the requirement for the first part of the assessment
is a literature review of key theories of how strategy is developed and implemented, and the
relationship between strategy, innovation and change, my confusion continued when your next
section stated that the intention was “to conclusively determine the relationship between
strategic management practices and the company’s performance”. Indeed there was very little
in the section on Theories that related to the assessment in a meaningful manner, or indeed
in the entire submission. I would have expected the “literature review of key theories of how
strategy is developed and implemented, and the relationship between strategy, innovation and
change” to have consisted of a logical structure such as: definition of strategy, how
strategies are developed, what tools can be used to develop a strategy, how they are
implemented, how organisations ensure strategies are maintained, how is change enveloped,
how is innovation accomplished, etc. (it should be your choice, not mine). The writing should
have encompassed a series of sections with these headings with your content following them
closely.
Your organisation analysis also did not follow the needs of the assessment, and in future I
strongly recommend that you use the three assessment questions as section headings for your
organisation analysis – that will give you a logical structure and help you to be sure that
nothing is omitted. Note that we are not interested in the strategy itself for this analysis,
but rather the process. Describe the process in more detail – who is involved, how long the
process takes, what actually happens, what tools are used in the strategy development, how it
is implemented, how is its performance reviewed, how often is the process repeated, etc. Be
sure to link back to the theory in multiple places, and any authors cited in these sections (e.g.
Hill and Jones ,1998) must have been introduced in the literature review.
Unfortunately, you have failed the assignment, and will normally be required to resit once the
university has confirmed the grade. The resubmission date will be confirmed via your
OnlineCampus account, but I suggest you consider starting work on the resubmission already,
being sure to address the specific issues raised in my feedback. It is unfortunate that you
did not submit an interim which would have addressed this issue at that time; I also see that
you do not appear to have been active in class; I recommend for your future modules that
you engage actively to help improve your understanding and your submission.
Mark: 30 (provisional)
Strategic Management
Michelle Theodore
Course No. MMK004
Robert Kennedy College
Abstract
The business environment is often unpredictable, even for old and established companies. It takes the actions of the organization by adopting suitable strategic management practices for it to be able to survive those times. Technology, as opined by a few researchers, has complicated the strategic management process, and it has an impact on the effectiveness of these practices. In today’s world, the effect of technology on an organization and how it does its production is enormous. From these new challenges have emerged, individuals who try to understand the technology and harness it for the good of the organization. These individuals have mastered human resource management, knowledge management, information management, and software development, among others.
There are several aspects of strategic management practices such as formulation, implementation, evaluation, and monitoring, and each has a specific impact on the activities of the company and its performance.
The influence that the strategic management practices have on the fortunes of the company needs to be understood if the company is to thrive in a competitive business environment. The impact is the same everywhere, and it is not dependent on the industry, environment, location, size of the company, or its age. It does not matter what kind of company it is; they all face the same dynamic challenges.
Some benefits accrue to a company that follows a good strategic management practice such as the company being able to allot resources to areas that are in dire need effectively, and this will make for better performance. Another benefit is that the management is ready to make crucial decisions that can have a lasting impact on its production processes.
The study of the influence of excellent strategic management practice on an organization is done using two American companies as case studies. The study was done using the knowledge-based and price discrimination theories as its theoretical foundation as this could explain the performance of a company using the kind of resources to ensure it is capable of formulating its strategic management policies.
The research done has shown that the implementation and monitoring of an efficient strategic management practice will ensure that the company’s operations are profitable when compared with companies that have no visible strategic management practice they follow. It also revealed that the companies which had a solid strategic management plan had a structured performance, which led to a competitive advantage. The organizations used as case study diligently followed their set strategic management practices, which were evident in their aims and objectives. The goals of these cases were met even if incentives had to be given to motivate staff and employees leading to the company’s growth.
This study will be of great significance to Investors, Researchers, Shareholders, Manufacturers, Policymakers, and the State & Federal Governments. It will serve as encouragement and a guide to managers, organizations as well as researchers and ensure they are fully committed to the ideals of the profession. It will undoubtedly have a positive impact on production.
Managers will be guided on how best to channel the organization’s resources (cash/stock) towards achieving the firm’s profitability.
Introduction
According to Dean, Shook, and Payne (2007, pp. 601-618), the data on the review of entrepreneurship and its impact on strategic management is inconsistent and so cannot be valid but is very necessary for an organization that wants growth and performance. Researchers such as Certo, Covin, and Dalton (2001, pp. 641–658) seem to support this assertion as they also opined that entrepreneurship and strategic management were closely related as they were both concerned with sustainable wealth creation and development of the company.
The U.S. industrial sector has mostly morphed and expanded within the last two decades, especially with the advent of technological processes and its impact on the need for more workforce. This transformation of the business environment has ensured that companies who want to thrive must prepare for continuous and dynamic change. Companies that are not ready to change with the times or are still operating traditional business processes have found themselves losing relevance and become moribund, out of sync with reality, and headed for corporate failure.
There have been more new companies that had not adapted to the changing trends in the business environments, and it took a toll on the company’s fortunes. The corporate meltdown that occurred in 2008 is a prime example of that as several companies declared bankruptcy as they could not adapt to changes in the business environment to become profitable in their industry.
This global meltdown proved in absolute terms that the environment impacts effective business practices, and one could not work efficiently without the other irrespective of the size of the company or the sector. It also proved that the business environment could be dynamic, turbulent, and highly competitive. It can be affected by events, news, and happenings from around the world. It drives and ruins economies, and it can affect the indices of trade and commerce; it can alter the influence of organizations and change the selection of leaders. Aremu (2000, p. 189) supports this notion as he said that an efficient business environment could unravel the complexity of doing business in a nation.
Management teams, in recent times, have been tasked with the responsibility of addressing the challenges that a hostile business environment might constitute. They face the internal activities that are liable to cause a rift in the managerial processes. Designing efficient strategic management can help to navigate the murky waters of entrepreneurship. According to Aremu (2000, p. 189), a company that can create and control an effective strategic management process will do exceptionally well in the competitive business environment.
The service sector is the largest employer of labor in the U.S. and is usually categorized into three subsectors- services, manufacturing, and materials. The service sector is estimated to account for over 70% of the US GDP, which says a lot about the industry. It is the same scenario in most developed economies, such as China, Japan, and Germany, among others.
The companies in the service sector usually provide services instead of physical products and so must have intensive knowledge of the business processes. The firms in this sector are typically professional skills-oriented rather than identifying with products or natural resources. Firms in this sector include media, information technology, I.C.T., as well as research and development firms.
According to Sharabati and Fuqaha (2013, pp. 23-25), strategic management is what will separate successful companies from unsuccessful companies. It is what will determine the strategy, vision, and goals for the company and i a critical process for the operations of the company. According to Porter (1985, p. 33), the primary aim that companies formulate a detailed strategic management process is to enable them to be competitive in any environment or economy. The other objective is to allow the business to decide how to mobilize scarce resources for its activities.
What this means is that all companies must, as a matter of urgency, prepare a detailed strategic management process they must follow if they are to survive in their business environment. Nag, Hambrick, Chen (2007, pp. 935–955) stress that detailed strategic management practices will lead to confidence among staff, employees, and the managerial team. They also opined that the Shareholders, Clients, and Board of Directors would also feel enthusiasm for the course the business is charting. The researchers also opined that an efficient practice would enable managers to make critical decisions on behalf of the owners, which will quicken the decision-making process, involve the efficient utilization of resources, and enhance the performance of the company in the long run.
Strategic management provides a roadmap to the organization, not just to the management team but also the Board of Directors, other members of the organizational structure, and the other stakeholders of the company.
Reports show that it is more than 20% of the workforce that works in the service sector, and this is continually increasing as more people are investing in the services sector and providing more jobs. In the services sector, the progress is at a steady pace, and this has proven difficult for companies to have a niche they can relatively exploit for their competitive advantage.
Companies that have previously utilized a traditional strategy approach in conducting their business practices have faced challenges that have proven to be a significant setback. A survey was done in 2017 that interviewed management teams of some top companies reveal that more than 70% of the respondents believe the company must clearly define its objective so employees and staff can know the plans for the company. Other equally essential goals were that the company must train employees to improve their experience; enhance service delivery as satisfied customers were the lifeblood of any company; more suitable talents must be sourced to strengthen the pool of workers; the performance management must be regularly monitored and evaluated; effectively utilize technology to streamline their production process.
Theories
There are several management theories that the researcher will discuss in an attempt to conclusively determine the relationship between strategic management practices and the company’s performance.
Knowledge-Intensive Theory
This theory shows that successful companies have developed a cost-effective way of attracting, training, and retaining employees through friendly policies. Employees have to feel they are an integral part of production if they are to provide any value to the production process. It also determines that a bottom-top approach is ideal, so the employees (the engine room of the production process) can know they are part of the decision making process.
Recruiters that rely on this approach in determining their company’s workforce show that they value practical know-how over the physical appearance of their staff. This will ensure that the company has a pool of talented employees whose skills will invariably translate to the innovativeness of the product or service.
Price Discrimination Theory
Porter (1985, p. 39) succinctly defines price discrimination as what occurs when the same product is sold to two different customers for different prices. This usually happens in a market that is not competitive, and the company can be said to be operating a monopoly. This marketing strategy is illegal in many countries as companies who practice this tends to only manufacture and sell products to customers who can pay the highest. According to Barney (2001, pp. 41–56), the company aims to make more profit if it practices price discrimination, but it will hurt the profit margin of the company in the long run. Researchers have shown that companies with products with a high-profit margin are more likely to benefit from price discrimination than companies whose production cost is just a little lesser than their sales margin.
A detailed Strategic management process takes into cognizance the company’s goals and objectives, mission, and vision and uses these data to develop plans and policies that will aid the company. A business that does not implement strategic management policies, according to Hevner, March, and Park (2004, pp. 75–105), is more likely to fail in the corporate world as it cannot have a competitive advantage in its industry.
Problem
There are several setbacks to efficient strategic management practices, and these factors severely limit the growth and profitability of any company. External Risks are “unpredictable and unpreventable” risks beyond the control of anyone such as natural disasters, inflation, recession, wars, securities fluctuations, interests, crime, unfavorable government legislation and, economic upheavals. It is also known as Systematic Risks, and it affects the entire industry. Internal Risks are risks resulting directly from the company’s operations. The factors of internal risks include human factors, operational factors, technological factors, and physical factors. It is the avoidable or internal risks that the company can prevent from occurring
While they may be several factors, the three factors that are mostly responsible for this are as follows: First, the business environment is hostile to businesses and is likely to kill off companies that will not adapt to the demands of the time. Second, technology evolves, and the companies must innovate with it. With the development of the new production process, more efficient equipment technology has simplified the way production is done, and customer preferences are what guide the kind of products companies manufacture. Third, as technology makes for a more efficient production process, it also blurs the production preferences of some industrial companies. Different products may have the same equipment, and companies often find themselves producing a wide range of products to satisfy a broader market.
Hitt et al. (2002, pp. 27-33) have consistently called for more investigation of the relationship between strategic management practices and organizational, entrepreneurial orientation. Researchers, such as Barringer, and Bluedorn (1999, pp. 421-444), have stated that there is a connection between strategic management and entrepreneurship, and this interrelatedness can impact on the performance of a company and provide it with competitive advantage if it can adapt and innovate.
An organization needs to able to compete and outperform other organizations if it is to succeed. The ability to compete does not have to be due to the size of the company or the number of employees. It also is not due to the funds it has at its disposal, although funds can give the company a competitive advantage. To succeed, the organization has to have a roadmap it follows, and opportunities or organizational core competencies it can exploit.
According to McGrath and MacMillian (2000, p. 39), there is no correct approach to designing an ideal strategy as what may work for one organization may not work for another. They stated that it would take the ability on the part of the management to combine favorable approaches that can increase the performance of the company.
Strategic Management
It is paramount that organizations and companies put in place an ideal strategic management plan if they are to cope with the uncertainties of the environment. According to Ginter, Swayne, and Duncan (2002, 11-18), this strategy provides management with some understanding of the challenges from government, competitors, stakeholders, shareholders, customers, and staff that they should expect and how they can be addressed or countered. Harrison (1999, pp. 27-51) agreed as he also stressed that strategic management was identical to some aspects of operational management but that the actions that guided operational management were often ambiguous and relied more on the uncertain emotions of decision-makers in the organization.
For a company desirous of scaling up like the two companies under review for this paper, strategic management is a vital policy to have. This will guide their actions and help them achieve or maintain performance. On some occasions, this strategic management policy is not as complicated as others. It may consist of goals and objectives and a timeline of when the company intends to achieve it. Strategic management is a necessary process as it develops structures and the systems that are vital for the growth of the organization (Harrison, 1999, p.22).
It is the responsibility of the management to note the weaknesses of the company and decide on ways to mitigate them or turn to strengths. Thompson and Strickland (1987, p.11) consider it the duty of the managers, from all the segments of the company, not just to streamline the process of identifying, implementing, and evaluating the strategies but also to ensure that it is executed and adhered to.
According to Mintzberg, Ahlstrand, and Lampel (1998, pp.83-95), there are five essential types of strategy such as evaluating the aims and objectives of the company and deciding how best to achieve them; the management team need to assess the strategic management programs of other companies and identify the program that will prove to be an indicator of success for them; the company has to identify its niche market by doing a comprehensive survey to get feedback from its customers; the company has to run a SWOT analysis to identify and know its weakness and threats and decide on the best way to combat them; implement the strategic management plan.
The qualified staff strength is one of the requirements for a company that intends to develop and scale up its production. The employees make these products for the public on behalf of the management team and must be equipped to do so effectively. A well-trained staff means a productive company.
Some strategists consider employees as more important than customers in the economic structure as it is the staff that attracts and keeps the customers. These employees are the face of the company are usually the persons the customers first encounter when they come to purchase products, so these employees must be organized, friendly, and are customer-centered.
As technology develops gradually, the line between the private lives of staff and management and their working lives in the company gets blurred. According to Ansoff (1984, pp.131-148), strategic management can help to provide companies with a buffer against unpleasant surprises by providing an enabling environment. Sharplin (1985, p.6) agrees with this assertion as he states that an efficient strategic management program is one that can enable a company to evaluate its competitiveness and improve on it by formulating plans and coordinating activities that can ensure it achieves its aims and objectives. Employees should always put the best interest of the company at heart even when they are not working. Employees can be motivated to adapt to changing technologies and use them for the progress of the company. Human Resources Manager has to understand that he is to aid his staff in adapting to new trends and models.
Corporate Entrepreneurship
Researchers such as Barney (2001, pp. 41–56) and Hamel (2000, pp. 28–32) state that there is a term like ‘corporate entrepreneurship,’ and it refers to a business set up solely to manufacture products or services to exploit real-time opportunities in the society. Barringer and Bluedorn (1999, pp. 421-444) support this view as he further said that corporate entrepreneurs were guided by the demands of society for specific products.
The organizational strategy has been a task of H.R. managers for decades now. However, technology has opened up new parts of the plan that were unknown then. The organizational strategy has several parts, and each of these parts has to come together if the organization is to benefit from its plan.
This innovativeness by some companies to take advantage of the opportunities presented by the society and identified by the strategic management experts often denotes proactiveness and highlights that the company is willing to take calculated risks to earn profits. According to Lumpkin and Dess (2005, pp. 104–107), there is some vital strategy literature that shows that specific strategy content is essential if entrepreneurship is to thrive. Researchers such as Hart (1992, pp. 327-351) explain that the process of strategic management is intriguing and can serve as a road map for new businesses.
Environment
The business environment consists mostly of technology, people, staff, government & policies, and location. Hevner, March, and Park (2004, pp. 75–105) succinctly describes it as the strengths, weakness, and opportunities a business will face. All companies must consider the environment as a factor when planning their strategic management procedures. The technology, emerging or available, is a considerable determinant of business processes as it will define the need for infrastructure, machinery, and equipment, as well as the production process. The agricultural sector constitutes the environment for our case study. The restructuring of the agrarian economy has been gradual, but it has continuously been evolving over the years. Lumpkin and Dess (2005, pp. 104–107) tried to liken it to the industrial revolution that brought a massive change to production as it encompasses the physical, technical, digital and biological themes.
Performance
The performance of a company is directly linked to its profitability, customer satisfaction and retention, market share, and market efficiency. The primary aim for all businesses, irrespective of industry, is to make profits, and Iravo, Ongori, and Munene (2013, pp. 897-928) put it succinctly when they stated that it is the performance of companies that differentiates between the successful and the unsuccessful companies.
Strategic management practice regards performance as a result of practical implementation. Several researchers have opined that performance is an integral part of strategic management as a company has to have high returns on investment, formulate, and drive policies before it can be termed successful.
Strategic Policy of Selected Companies
The strategic plan for two companies was analyzed and constructively discussed for this paper. The companies that were used for this study opted to remain anonymous, and so they are referred to as Case Company One and Case Company Two. Please find below the empirical findings derived during our analysis:
Case Company One
Case Company One is a medium scale producer of household consumables.
Financial
The chief financial goals of Case Company One is a company with just over 205 employees, and their objectives for this period are to have a competitive advantage in their niche, and this requires substantial investments to purchase equipment and machinery and also train employees. The company utilizes a detailed business plan which shows its developmental process and milestones it is to achieve at set periods. The management team of Case Company One is so determined to have a sizable market share that employees are willing to invest their money in the process. The company does its operations in a rented factory but has also purchased an expanse of land for siting the company’s operations soon.
Customer
Households are the primary consumers of the products. Case Company One produces soaps, detergents, toothpaste, and it appears to have a small but firm customer base. Case Company One has been in operation since 2014 and is always trying to innovate and develop more products to meet demand. The management team still considers Case Company One to be a small company as it is still privately owned and does not have a rigid Board of Directors involved in its managerial process. However, Case Company One has the opportunity to scale up its market base if it can increase its production capacity and fine-tune its marketing.
The company produces several products, but there is not any product t can refer to as its innovative product. Case Company One has not encountered any setback in either the production or marketing as it does not take significant risks.
Internal
The Chief Executive Officer has never to coerce the management into the manufacturing of a particular product regardless of his belief that it would be profitable. He believes this should be a collective decision, and so any decision concerning the company must be deliberated on by the management team, and everyone’s idea is welcome. Whenever these kinds of weighty choices are taken, the management team will take into cognizance the unpredictability of the market and the unreliability of the business environment.
Case Company One must also take advantage of the technological developments and apply it in his production process. This will improve his efficiency and production capacity. The recent change in machinery is reported to have increased the production output by as much as 80% while only increasing the production cost by an extra 30%.
The management team had set a 5-year production target for each product which the company has achieved during the third quarter of 2019 and so the immediate objective is to maintain the production capacity without putting stress on the machinery.
Learning & growth
Employees are a vital part of the manufacturing process, and Case Company One realizes the potentials that well-trained employees can offer the company and has taken concrete steps to train and inspire their employees. Employees are provided with the opportunity to purchase products at highly discounted rates. Knowing that they may be the end, consumers of the products seem to motivate the employees to put their hearts into the production process. High performing employees are also rewarded periodically. This will ensure that everyone puts in their best, which maximizes profits for the company. The management team believes that this approach has stimulated production and increased monthly profits. The growth of other companies in our industry is also of paramount concern as the C.E.O. thinks the company can only grow by lifting others. There is a high level of cooperation between the Case Company One and other companies within its niche. This has aided the company in finding out solutions to any problems it may encounter in production.
Case Company Two
Case Company Two is a medium scale producer of high-quality noodles
Financial
Case Company Two manufactures high-quality noodles for a fraction of the price of commercially available noodles. The company is owned by two partners who pooled financial resources to start up the company two decades ago. One of the co-founders is actively involved in the daily running of the company while the other is semi-retired due to the death of his spouse. The two partners believe that there must be proper bookkeeping for the business to thrive, and often, an external auditor is called upon to vet the financial activities of the company. The costs of equipment and machinery are very vital as it is pivotal in their records. Still, Case Company Two has kept its production schedule up by purchasing the most efficient equipment regardless of the market price or availability of cheaper but inferior substitutes.
Customer
The customer has always been the priority of the management of Case Company Two. The company manufactures only one product although with several variants and so must be able to attend to the needs of the customers. The noodles are of exceptionally high quality, and this has stimulated demands from even States that are far away from the location of the company.
The company also has sales outlets and uses marketing channels such as traditional and online markets. It also utilizes customer feedbacks for determining the kinds of products it should m. It utilizes a product approach for its sales and marketing. Case Company Two knows that while the parents and adults are the people with the purchasing power, it is the children that are its niche audience. This ideal does not affect its profitability in any way because if a child wants the noodles, the parents will buy the noodles.
Internal
The progress in technology has enabled the company to manufacture noodles in different variants efficiently. The different flavors have put the choice back in the hands of the end consumer. It is a highly competitive business environment, and production experience will count in favor of Case Company Two. The founders of the company are trained and have an extensive educational background. The production staff also are trained in resource management and strategic management. During periods of high demands such as holidays, Case Company Two employs extra employees to deal with the spike in demand.
Learning & growth
Case Company Two has periodic training and refresher courses for its staff and management. They are trained in the business processes and also on handling new equipment and technologies. There has been a rapid change from the primary method the company handled its production process to a dynamic way the company presently utilizes. This has increased the profits of the company and instilled confidence by staff and customers about the product. The production manager is highly skilled & experienced and is empowered to make quick decisions as it concerns production.
Hill and Jones (1998, pp. 15–25) opine that monitoring and evaluation should be considered as essential parts of strategic management as this is where you get feedback and honest reviews about the company and the products. Both cases studies have production experience in the making of fast-moving consumer goods and have their brand loyalty. Both companies appear to use external sources for monitoring and evaluating their activities, and this was impartial as it helped identify areas that needed improvements. They also had internal monitoring and evaluation, but it was not as detailed as the external sources. The companies under review were medium scale enterprises and probably had the same business management principles.
The employees in both companies said that they spent most of their daylight hours wither working or in each other’s company. This means they had virtually no social activities planned. Some employees had other family members in the staff pool as they liked the working conditions of the company and so encouraged their family members to apply.
The results from the companies used for the case study show that most companies, small businesses, or massive corporations define their goals and objectives, and most have strategic plans, even if it were not to be scaling or increasing its rate of production. Management teams of the two selected companies were focused on finding innovative products or thinking about how to make increased sales and profitability.
The founders of the companies also had an idea of who their successor will be, as this can cause a rift if it is not delicately managed. The companies provided high-quality consumable products to their customers and make the customers feel like they are part of the production process as they collect their recommendations and criticisms and try to affect the changes the customers’ desire.
Applications of theories
Case Company One has applied the knowledge based theories in its performances. The management has ensured that the staff are fully trained in the use of production software which has cut down production time and increased the company’s turnover rate. Innovations in the production have improved the taste and nutrition of the noodles. The requisition of raw materials, such as wheat, sugar, salt and vegetable oils, is efficiently done and the stocks are accounted for on periodic basis.
The owners of Case Company Two are strategists and are constantly evolving their production line to meet increased demands from the public. The company trainings for staff and employees ensure that they are informed about current dynamic production practices.
Ethics in research
The details of the companies used for the case study are kept confidential to give these companies discretion as they desire. According to Robson (1993, p.7), people always provide more information if they are guaranteed anonymity during the research. The managers I discussed within the build-up to this paper specifically requested anonymity as one of the criteria of divulging information.
Of course, there were some ethical issues encountered during the writing of this paper as we had to reveal data but not share the source of that data.
Measuring Financial and Non-Financial Performance
The performance of a company is a determinant of its success. Sharabati and Fuqaha (2013, pp.41-75) opined that profits could be used as an indicator of its financial performance. This assertion is also supported by Moore (2000, pp. 183-208) and Oster (1995, p.13). In the world of competition to be in the market is very important for any company. One of the measures to sustain in the game is to provide credit to the customers as it helps in retain not only customers but also increases sales. According to Poister and Streib (2005, pp. 45-56), a successful company must have a strategic plan that aligns its strategies with, as this is what will evaluate its performance system. Companies who can readily access funds for its production are often regarded as successful, but the ability to get funds is not a true reflection of the company’s strengths.
Another way of measuring the non-financial performance of a company is by using metrics to determine its acceptability in the market. McCarthy (2007, pp. 156-164) stated that a company must show transparency in its activities if it is to have the trust of the shareholders.
The financial performance of companies must be in tandem with the production output, according to Kareithi and Lund (2012, pp.1-8), if it is to be considered as a reliable measure.
Delimitations
This study is specifically concerned with the impact of efficient strategic management practices on a company’s competitive advantage and organizational performance – evidence from American companies. The environment, in this sense, comprises the physical production environment, the community environment, socio-economic status, skills, and commitment.
Limitations
Some limitations were encountered when researching for this paper. A significant barrier was the fact that we only utilized data from just two companies. Another limitation was that we could only target companies that were in the United States. Finally, the limited data available offline and online was a huge setback as it made the impact difficult to assess. Future research should be done in other sectors of the economy to determine the impact of effective strategic management practices.
Empirical Review
The empirical review of strategic management, particularly in the companies used as a case study, is done primarily by assessing the strategies and plans and relating it with the performance after a defined period. Various works of literature describe strategic management as a complex mix of planning, implementation, and execution of strategies while realizing the importance of the environment in affecting the process. This process of diligently followed will increase the efficiency of the company, the effectiveness of the staff, and its performance.
This empirical review is limited as the average company utilizes several planning techniques, so the researcher was unable to determine what worked best for the company. This is supported by authors such as Kareithi and Lund (2012, pp.13), McCarthy (2007, pp. 156-164), and Moore (2000, pp. 183-208) who opined that companies desirous of growth must be innovative and be prepared to evolve as it periodically evaluates its strategies. They further suggested that management must critically analyze its environments, formulate a workable strategy, and implement plans to meet up with any crisis.
A few scholars have attempted to clearly define the relationship between efficient strategic management practice and high performance in all spheres from a company. There are a lot of literary works that highlight some key areas that are worth investigating. One of the scholars, Blackmon (2008, pp.13-22), believed that if the company utilized an approach where it compared several methods, it would find that divisions that were not as profitable as others had inadequate plans to handle negative impacts. Another researcher, Smith and DeGregorio (2001, p. 5), discovered that firms like nongovernmental organizations that were for non-profit found out that a detailed strategic plan had a profound impact on their non-financial activities. Hu et al. (2014, pp.102-111) had a survey that showed that strategic management made it easier for the N.G.O.s to deliver on their projects of satisfying the community needs. More prominent companies are more likely to develop strategic management plans than smaller companies, and this may affect their profitability (Smith and DeGregorio 2001, pp.66-81).
Discussion and Conclusion
The concern of this paper is with the impact of efficient strategic management practices on a company’s competitive advantage and organizational performance – evidence from American companies. It showed how companies could benefit from a detailed strategic management policy document. The researcher explained the processes in strategic management practices and how they affected the successes and performances of companies, using two companies for the case study. Literature that confirmed that there was an underlying relationship between efficient strategic management practices and the production of organizations was discussed. The business environment was clearly defined as a factor that companies must consider in planning as it influenced its implementation of the strategic management plan.
Business environments are often hostile to businesses and lethal to organizations that do not have a strategic plan on how to mitigate these inherent risks. While the strategies employed by the two medium scale businesses used for the case study, they both had employees who were trained and opted to deliver products of high value to the end consumer. This ensured that the organizations had a customer base for their products.
Both businesses put the welfare of their staff and employees as paramount issues, and the staff were loyal to the companies and aided these companies in adapting to the very turbulent and competitive business environment.
The data used for this paper was derived from studying the activities of two medium scale businesses in the U.S. These businesses varied in their business operations and procedure, and the only thing they had in common was the desire to grow their companies to meet up with the ever-increasing demand.
This paper will prove most relevant to companies, not just in the United States that constitute the environment for the companies we used as a case study, but to every company irrespective of location as organizations face the same struggles and challenges. Consider that potential business risks are in various forms, but all pose the same threat of affecting the company’s ability to meet its target or achieve its financial goals. Businesses must strive to reduce risks and minimize its mitigating effects by having strategic plans and enabling stringent safety precautions.
The data gotten during the research shows that all businesses feel the impact of the environment as it dictates the level of their performance. Still, comprehensive strategic management will help with the organizational, entrepreneurial orientation.
It is recommended that the management team should realize that having a strategic plan is essential if a company will survive in this competitive business ecosystem. The business has to be flexible and adapt to the necessary changes in trends. It also has to be adept at tackling threats and utilizing opportunities.
Reference
Ansoff, H.I. (1984) Strategic issue Management. Strategic Management Journal 1: 131-148.
Aremu, M. A. (2000) “Enhancing Organizational Performance through Strategic Management: Conceptual and Theoretical Approach.”
Barney, J.B. (2001) Is the Resource-Based Theory a Useful Perspective for Strategic Management Research? Yes. Academy of Management Review; 26, (1), pp. 41–56.
Barringer, B. R., and Bluedorn, A. C. (1999) The relationship between corporate entrepreneurship and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 20, pp. 421-444.
Blackmon, V. Y. (2008) Strategic planning and organizational performance: An investigation using the balanced scorecard in non-profit organizations. Ph.D. dissertation, Capella University, United States. Retrieved August 2014, from dissertations and theses: Full-text database (publication no. AAT 3311386).
Certo, S. T., Covin, J. G., Daily, C. M., and Dalton, D. R. (2001) Wealth and the effects of founder management among IPO-stage new ventures. Strategic Management Journal, 22(Special Issue), pp. 641–658.
Covin, J. G., Green, K. M., and Slevin, D. P. (2006) Strategic Process Effects on the Entrepreneurial Orientation-Sales Growth Rate Relationship. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 30(1), pp. 57-81.
Dean, M., A. Shook, C.L. and Payne, G. T. (2007) The Past, present, and future of entrepreneurship research: data analytic, trends, and training. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 31 (4), pp. 601-618.
Ginter P.M., Swayne L.E. & Duncan W.J. (2002) Strategic Management of Healthcare Organisations, 4th edn. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.
Hamel, G. (2000). Leading the Revolution, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Harrison E.F. (1999) The Managerial Decision Making Process. Houghton Mifflin, Boston, MA.
Hart, S. L. (1992) An integrative framework for strategy-making processes. Academy of Management Review, 17, pp. 327-351.
Hevner, A. R., March, S. T., and Park, J. (2004): “Design research in information systems research,” M.I.S. Quarterly, 28(1), pp. 75–105.
Hill, C.W.L., & Jones, G.R., 1998. Strategic Management, An integrated Approach. Fourth Edition, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston New York.
Hitt, M.A., Ireland, R.D., Camp, S.M. and Sexton, D.L. (2002) Strategic entrepreneurship: integrating entrepreneurial and strategic management perspectives, In Hitt, M.A., Ireland, R.D., Camp, S.M. and Sexton, D.L. (eds.) Strategic Entrepreneurship: Creating a New Mindset. Oxford: Blackwell.
Hu, Q., Kapucu, N., & O’Byrne, L. (2014). Strategic planning for community-based small non-profit organizations: Implementation, benefits, and challenges. The Journal of Applied Management and Entrepreneurship, 19 (1), 83-101.
Iravo, M., Ongori, J. & Munene, C. (2013). Factors affecting the performance of hotels and restaurants in Kenya. A case of Kisii County. Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business. 4(12), 897-928.
Kareithi, RNM., & Lund, C. (2012). Review of N.G.O. Performance research published in academic journals between 1996 and 2008. South African Journal of Science, 108 (11/12), 1-8.
Lumpkin, G.T., and Dess, G.G. (2005) Entrepreneurial orientation. In: Hitt, M.A., and Ireland, R.D. (eds.) The Blackwell Encyclopaedic Dictionary Of Entrepreneurship: Blackwell Encyclopaedia of Management. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing: pp. 104–107.
McCarthy, J. (2007). The ingredients of financial transparency. Non-profit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 36 (1), 156-164.
McGrath, R. G., and MacMillian, I. (2000) The entrepreneurial mindset. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
Mintzberg, H., Ahlstrand, B. W., and Lampel, J. (1998): “Strategy Safari: A Guided Tour Through the Wilds of Strategic Management,” Free Press, New York, NY.
Moore, M. H. (2000). Managing for value: Organizational strategy in for-profit, non-profit, and governmental organizations. Non-profit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 29 (1), 183-208.
Morris, M.H., D. Kuratko, and J. G. Covin. (2008) Corporate Entrepreneurship and Innovation, 2nd Ed. Mason: South-Western CENGAGE Learning
Nag, R.; Hambrick, D. C.; Chen, M.-J, What is strategic management? Inductive derivation of a consensus definition of the field. Strategic Management Journal. Volume 28, Issue 9, pages 935–955, September 2007.
Oster, S. M. (1995). Strategic management for non-profit organizations: Theory and cases. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Poister, T. H., & Streib, G. (2005). Elements of strategic planning and management in municipal government: Statuses after two decades. Public Administration Review, 65 (1), 45-56.
Porter, Michael E. (1985) “Competitive Advantage” New York, Free Press
Penrose, E. T. (1959). The Theory of the Growth of the Firm. New York: John Wiley
Robson, C (1993) Real World Research: A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner-Researchers. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
Sharabati, A.A, and Fuqaha, S.J (2013). Impact of Strategic Management on the Jordanian Pharmaceuticals Manufacturing Organisation Business Performance. International Review of Management and Business Research Vol. 3 Issue.2
Sharplin (1985) “Strategic Management” (New York: McGraw-Hill) p. 6.
Smith KG, DeGregorio D. (2001) Bisociation, discovery, and the role of entrepreneurial action. In: Hitt M.A., Ireland R.D., Camp S.M., Sexton,
Thompson, A. A. Jr. & Strickland, A. J. (1987). “Strategic Management: Concepts and Case.” Illinois: Home wood.